:CM
CO
THE LIFE
OF
JAMES DUKE OF ORMOND;
CONTAINING AN ACCOUNT OF
THE MOST REMARKABLE AFFAIRS OF HIS TIME,
AND PARTICULARLY
OF IRELAND UNDER HIS GOVERNMENT
WITH
AN APPENDIX
AND
A COLLECTION OF LETTERS,
SERVING TO
VERIFY THE MOST MATERIAL FACTS IN THE SAID HISTORY.
A NEW EDITION,
CAREFULLY COMPARED WITH THE ORIGINAL MSS.
VOLUME I.
OXFORD:
AT THE UNIVERSITY PRESS.
M.DCCC.LI.
^n
ADVERTISEMENT.
THE work of which a new edition is now offered to the public first appeared in three volumes folio in the years 1735, 1736, the third volume of which containing the Letters was printed before the other two in order that the paginal references to it might be made correctly in the first and second volumes. It is hoped that the present edition will be found more accurate than the former, as the whole has been carefully compared with the original MSS. now pre- served in the Bodleian Library, and especially the Letters, the orthography of which has been restored throughout. For convenience of reference the pages of the folio edition have been placed in the margin on the right hand, and the several paragraphs of each book have been numbered on the left. A full account of Mr. Carte and his works may be seen in the Lite- rary Anecdotes by John Nichols, London 1812. vol. II. p. 471—518.
a 2
CONTENTS OF VOL. I.
THE AUTHOR'S PREFACE i — xvi
INTRODUCTION xvii — cxxii
BOOK I.
Containing an account of his grace's birth, education, and marriage, and of the affairs of Ireland, till the lord deputy Wentworth entered upon the government of that kingdom .
Introduction, containing memoirs of the Ormond family .... Page i *
The duke of Ormond's birth, 3. his education, 4. his marriage, 7. his going over into Ireland 9
State of affairs in Ireland, 10. in an- cient times, ibid, in the reign of queen Elizabeth, n. in the reign of king James I 12
The plantation of Ulster 15
The king's care of the church and clergy of Ulster 17
Account of parliaments in Ireland 18
The history of the parliament in 1613 19
Plantations in Leinster, 22. of Wex- ford, Longford, and Leytrim, ibid.
Abuses therein 24
Inquiries into defective titles .... 26
The case of the Byrnes 27
Penal laws 32
The act of uniformity ibid.
The act of supremacy 35
The oath of supremacy 38
Sir John Davy's speech about it 39 Incapacities contracted by recu- sancy 43
The lenity of the government . . ibid. The state of the army and revenue 44 Schemes for improving the reve- nue 47
The court of wards 49
The necessity of increasing the
army ibid.
The graces 51
A contribution for paying the
army 52
The behaviour of recusants .... 53
BOOK II.
Containing an account of the duke of Orrnond's conduct, and of the affairs of Ireland, from lord Stafford's entering on the government to the breaking out of the rebellion.
ANNO 1633. gets a contribution for the pay o*
THE lord deputy Wentworth's ar- the army 58
rival at Dublin, 55. his treatment The earl of Ormond's zeal in pro- of the privy-council, 56. he restores moting it, ibid, his coming to the discipline of the army, 57. he Dublin ibid.
* The pages referred to are those of the folio edition, which are given in the margin of the present.
CONTENTS OF VOL. I.
Reasons for calling a parliament 59
The lord deputy's scheme for ma- naging the parliament 61
The ancient way of levying subsi- dies 62
ANNO 1634.
Passsages in parliament 63
The earl of Ormond disobeys an order of the lord deputy 64
The earl of Kildare's dispute with the lord deputy 66
The lord deputy's harsh treatment of great men 67
The condition of the church of Ire- land 68
The lord deputy's care in reforming the church, 68. his letter to arch- bishop Laud 69
Grievances of the Ulster clergy. . 71
The lord deputy's redress thereof ib.
The church of Ireland brought to conformity with the church of England 73
A proposal for a mint 79
Proceedings about the graces . . 80 ANNO 1635.
Proceedings on the commission for defective titles 81
Improvements of the revenue, 83. in the customs, ibid, and in other branches 84
The lord deputy's care in encourag- ing commerce, 84. his impartial justice, 86. his severity in the case of sir Piers Crosby, ibid, and of
lord Mountnorris 87
ANNO 1639.
The Scots rebellion, 87. fomented by cardinal Richlieu 88
The king's preparations against the covenanters 89
He marches against them 90
The pacification 90. broke by the covenanters ibid.
The king resolves to call a parlia- ment 91
ANNO 1640.
Proceedings of the parliament in Ireland 93
The earl of Ormond's behaviour thereon 94
The case of privilege of convoca- tion ibid.
The case of the bishop of Killala 95
An army raised under the command of the earl of Ormond 97
A rendezvous of the Irish army 99
The meeting of the parliament in June ibid.
Proceedings of the Irish parlia- ment 100
The Scots enter England 103
The treaty of Rippon ibid.
Orders sent to the earl of Or- mond • 104
Proceedings in the Irish parlia- ment, 105. of the Irish commons for reducing the subsidies, 106 and the prosecution of the earl of Strafford 107
The Irish committee sent to Eng- land 108
The manner of passing the remon- strance in the house of com- mons ibid.
Mistaken in the remonstrance .. 109
The earl of Ormond opposes the remonstrance in the house of lords H5
The remonstrance presented to the house of commons in England ib.
The death of the lord deputy Wan- desford n6
The earl of Ormond proposed to succeed him, 116. but opposed by the Irish committee and the earl of Arundel 1 16
The case of Idough ibid.
The remonstrance presented to the king 118
ANNO 1641.
The meeting of the Irish parlia- ment 119
Proceedings and debates therein 120
The protestation of both houses ibid.
A committee of the lords in Eng- land , 121
CONTENTS OF VOL. I.
vn
Grievances complained of by the lords 121
Applications to the house of com- mons in England 122
Proceedings of the Irish house of commons 123
The case of privilege of John Fitz- gerald 124
Debates in the house of lords about the queries to be put to the judges 125
Proceedings in the Irish parliament about the impeachment of the lord chancellor Bolton, the bishop of Deny, and sir Gerard Low- ther, 127. for disbanding the Irish army 132
The king's design of sending the dis- banded Irish abroad opposed by
the parliament 134
A bill of attainder of the earl of Strafford 135
Artifice to engage the king to pass the bill 136
Marquis of Ormond refuses the garter 137
The distress of the government of Ireland ibid.
The king's answer to the griev- ances 140
Proceedings of the Irish house of commons, 144. in relation to the queries, ibid, with regard to the university of Dublin, 147. and the impeachments, 148. about the lords' power of judicature. ... 149
The return of the Irish committee from England 152
BOOK III.
Containing an account of the duke of Ormond's conduct, and of the affairs of Ireland, from the beginning of the rebellion, October 1641, to the cessation in September 1643.
AN inquiry into the causes of the re- bellion, and the agents in it. . 154
Characters of the chief conspirators ; of lord Macguire, 156. of Roger More, ibid, colonel Richard Plun- ket, 157. of sir Phelim O'Neile 158
The lord Macguire' s account of the conspiracy ibid.
The gentry of the pale not concerned in it 164
The negligence and security of the lords justices 165
A discovery of the conspiracy . . 167
The consternation occasioned by the discovery 170
Measures taken for the defence of
Dublin, 171. and of the king- dom ibid.
A remonstrance of the rebels in the
county of Cavan 174
The cruelty of sir Phelim O'Neile 1 76 Numbers of the English massa- cred 177
Declarations of the rebels 178
They forge a commission from the
king 179
The manifesto of the Ulster rebels 182 The declaration of the Longford
rebels 183
Passages in the north of Ireland 184 Character of the lords justices. . 190 The state of the army in Ireland 192
THE PREFACE.
TO
THE RIGHT HONOUEABLE
THE EARL OF ARRAN.
MY LORD,
THE subject of this work naturally recommends it to your lordship's patronage. It containeth an account of the life and actions of your grandfather, whose amiable virtues and excellent talents formed the completest cha- racter which appeared in the age wherein he lived. His noble ancestors had in a course of some hundreds of years set him a constant example of hereditary loyalty ; but his was distinguished by such eminent trials, tempt- ations, and difficulties, as very rarely happen, and to which few minds are equal. The prevailing wickedness of the times wherein he lived, and the various circum- stances of his own affairs, and those of the kingdoms which were the scene of his actions, served only to add a lustre to his virtues, and to set in a fuller light the wisdom and integrity of a conduct, which deserves the admiration of all ages, and was scarce ever paralleled in any.
The world hath too long wanted such an example of heroic virtue, loyalty, and honour, as is fit for the imita- tion of latest posterity. I have in this work endea-
ORMOND, VOL. i. b
ii DEDICATION.
voured to supply this defect, to do some justice to the memory of that truly great and good man, and to pre- serve some memorials of your illustrious ancestors ; and I now offer it to your lordship, as a mark of my inviola- ble attachment to the house of ORMOND, and of the profound respect with which I am,
MY LORD,
Your lordship's most obliged, most obedient,
and devoted servant,
THO. CARTE.
THE PREFACE.
IT is now near six years ago that the earl of Arran delivered to me 153 bundles of his grandfather the first duke of Or- mond's letters and papers, all indorsed with the name of the writer, the date of each letter, and the time of its receipt marked in his grace's hand-writing. Some endeavours had been used to methodize these papers, and a catalogue had been taken of them by captain Brydall in the year 1698, but many mistakes had been made in the arrangement thereof in the order of time ; the greatest part of those mistakes being occasioned by the confusion which the legal computation of the year in England, different from all the rest of the world, necessarily produceth with regard to the space of near three months, which pass after the commencement of each year in foreign parts, before the be- ginning of it in this country. This confusion I endeavoured to remedy ; and having digested these papers in the best order I could, I caused them to be bound up in twenty-seven large vo- lumes in folio, that they might be better preserved and more ready for use ; and then took care to page each leaf for the more easy reference thereto upon occasion. These volumes are marked on the back, and distinguished by the letters A, B, &c. to DD ; and are accordingly referred to in the bottom of the pages of the following history, wherever I conceived it necessary to verify any account given in it, by a reference to the original letter or writing from whence it was taken.
2 These volumes containing only a series of letters and papers to the end of 1651, and some in the beginning of the following year, it was necessary to seek for other materials to enable me to give an account of the latter part of the duke of Ormond's Life, which I had undertaken to write. I was persuaded that his grace, who had preserved his papers with so much care and method from the time of his first entry upon public business, when it was perhaps dangerous as well as difficult to keep them,
IV
THE PREFACE.
could not but continue the same care in his later employments, in his riper years, and in more settled times, when the preserva- ii tion of his papers exposed him to no hazards. It seemed strange to me, that upon inquiry I could not find out where these later papers were, or that they were so much as preserved. A letter, which I met with of Mr. Henry Gascoigne the duke's secretary to sir Robert Southwell in 1689, affirming, that they were then all in his hands at the castle of Kilkenny, confirmed me in my notion that they were still in being, and that they were to be found in that place. This made me resolve upon a journey to Ireland to search my self for what I so much wanted, and the earl of Arran was pleased to authorize me to bring over such letters and papers as I found for my purpose. The success was answerable to my wishes : I found in the evidence-room at Kil- kenny about fourteen wicker bins (each large enough to hold an hogshead of wine in bottles) covered with unwieldy books of stewards' accounts ; but which upon examination appeared to be full of papers, and to contain a series of papers of state, orders, resolutions, and letters of the privy council of Ireland, the de- spatches of the king and secretaries of state in England, his grace's own letters, and those of other great men who corre- sponded with him, from before the restoration of king Charles II to the year 1686. There being no bookbinder at Kilkenny, I was forced to transport these on three Irish cars to Dublin, where I was continually employed for several months in digesting them, in order to have them bound up like the others. Such papers as upon perusal did not appear useful to my subject 1 sent back to Kilkenny, and bound up the rest in volumes, the folios marked by the letters EE, FF, &c. to YY ; and the quar- tos A, B, &c. Some of these marks comprehend several volumes, as particularly the duke of Ormondes own letters take up four in folio distinguished by WW. i. 2. 3. 4. and two in quarto marked G. i. and 2. These volumes contain the letters which he wrote to his friends and the secretaries of state; for the other letters penned by his grace's secretaries on various occa- sions in the course of his government, I found preserved in vo- lumes already bound, where they were (at the time they were wrote) entered, like the petitions presented to him, and the lord lieutenant's orders thereon ; of which I found likewise many volumes. 3 Not content with this large collection of materials, I made it
THE PREFACE. v
my business to procure all other memoirs whereof I could get intelligence relating to the times whereof I was to write, that I might be fully enabled to set every transaction in its true light. I read over the journals of both houses of parliament, and got transcripts of such passages as related to my subject ; which, iii with other materials that I had means and opportunity of col- lecting, I bound up in several volumes marked Ireland, I, IT, &c. and have sometimes referred to them as distinguished by those marks. The journal of Owen O'Neile's campaigns was wrote by an officer who served under him, and was communicated to me by Mr. Henry O'Neile of Church-street in Dublin, who had it with other curious collections from the late Mr. Tully O'Neile. The lord viscount Chichester's book of the Plantation of Ulster I had from Mr. Barry of Finglas, grandson to Matthew Barry, who was clerk of the council of Ireland from the time of the earl of Strafford's government till after the year 1682. The truly honourable earl of Huntingdon, conceiving they might be useful to my work, gave me all the papers of sir John Davys, formerly attorney-general of Ireland, and appointed lord chief justice of England, whose sole daughter and heir was married to his lordship's great grandfather Henry earl of Huntingdon. It is chiefly from these papers and from lord Chichester's book that I have taken the account -of the Plantation of Ulster, and the state of affairs in Ireland before the time of lord Strafford's government. The learned and hospitable bishop of Clogher was not in Dublin during the time of my first expedition to Ireland ; which obliged me to make another voyage thither to see his very valuable collections, among which six volumes of Mr. Matthew Barry's, Dr. Madding' s manuscripts, (a catalogue of which is to be seen in the Catalogus Manusc,riptorum Anglice et ffibernice,) and many other curious pieces relating to the affairs of that kingdom are to be found. These with great humanity and free- dom he communicated to me, and from them I have taken seve- ral accounts of affairs, as well previous to the rebellion as hap- pening in the course of it, which are referred to in the course of this history.
4 The council books of Ireland were burnt in the fire which hap- pened in the castle of Dublin, and consumed the council chamber in the year 1711. The duke of Ormondes papers have sup- plied a great deal of this loss for the years wherein he had the government of that kingdom ; and possibly might have supplied
vi THE PREFACE.
it entirely for his time, if many of his bound books of collections had not been lost by his lending and communicating of them too freely. Besides a multitude of papers which he imparted to the lord chancellor Clarendon, in order to his drawing up that Historical View of the Affairs of Ireland during the Rebellion which was printed at London in 1720, which papers after his death the duke of Ormond endeavoured by repeated instances iv with his executors to recover, there were several bound volumes, containing all the papers which were interchanged in his treaties with the Irish confederates and all passages in those treaties. I have seen among his graced loose papers various references to these books, which yet I have not had the good fortune to find. Two other books, the one containing the letters of the lords jus- tices and council of Ireland to the king, the lord lieutenant, and the house of commons of England, from the breaking out of the Irish rebellion, till Jan. 1643—4, when the duke*of Or- mond entered upon the government of Ireland : the other con- taining all the papers presented or prepared by all parties to be offered to the king and council of England, in order to the set- tlement of Ireland after the restoration, seem likewise to be lost. But this loss is repaired by copies of these two books, taken in 1 680, which are in the library of the duke of Chandos, whose generosity and humanity distinguish him, as much as his dignity, above the rest of the world. These his grace, ever ready to en- courage any public work, vouchsafed to communicate to me, and they served to complete the series of the letters of those lords justices, many of which I had met with among the duke of Or- mond's papers attested by Matthew Barry, clerk of the council, and which being collated with the copies in those books, I found to be exactly the same ; so that there cannot be the least reason to dispute the authority of the rest.
5 There are some other accounts of the affairs of Ireland during the rebellion, which I have had opportunities of consulting, and which therefore it may be proper to mention. One is entitled, An Aphorismical Discovery of treasonable faction, being an ac- count of the affairs of Ireland from 1641 to 1652, by N. S. who styles himself secretary to Owen Roe O'Neile. It is among the bishop of Clogher's manuscripts in folio, and is marked No. VIII. but is wrote with so much partiality, fury, and virulence, and contains throughout it such notorious falsehoods., even in the re- lation of the same facts which are mentioned and related other-
THE PREFACE. vii
wise in the nuncio's memoirs, that I could make no use of it, because it deserved no credit. Another was communicated to me by Mr. Henry Pluncket of the county of Meath, whose uncle was the compiler thereof. It would make a very large volume in folio, and is a collection of a vast number of relations of passages that happened in the Irish war, made by a society of gentlemen who lived in that time, and were eyewitnesses of many of those passages. It is not digested into a proper order, but is wrote with great temper, modesty, candour, and regard to truth ; the v compiler upon all occasions taking care to distinguish what was the result of his own knowledge from what he learned either by common report or by relation from others, that the reader might make his own judgment of the measure of credit which each re- lation in his book deserved. And I must do the author the justice to say, that wherever he asserts any thing of his own knowledge, and as a certain fact, I have found him still confirmed by the relations I met with in the duke of Ormondes papers. I have borrowed from this collection several parts of the charac- ters of the principal persons concerned in the rebellion, and some other passages mentioned in this history, and quoted from thence under the title of Pluncket's Memoirs. 6 There is still another account of those affairs, which I have frequent occasion to quote by the name of the Nuncio's Memoirs. It takes up above 7000 pages in folio, consisting of several vo- lumes, and is wrote in Latin, the title of it being, De Hceresis Anglicance intrusione et progressu, et de bello Catholico ad annum 1641 in Hibernia coepto, exindeque per aliquot annos gesto, com- mentarius. It was wrote after the nuncio's death by an Irish Roman catholic priest, whom Thomas Baptista Rinuccini, great chamberlain to the grand duke of Tuscany, employed to digest his brother's papers, and reduce them into the form of a narra- tion. The compiler was a very rigid man in his principles with regard to the immunities of the clergy, the papal power, and the lawfulness of rebellion for the sake of religion ; and appears infinitely zealous for the nuncio's honour. But notwithstanding his prepossession in these respects, he appears always to have a great regard to truth, and to be very fair and candid in his re- lation of occurrences. These he generally takes out of the let- ters and accounts sent to the nuncio, as events happened, by those concerned in them, and there are no more of these relations than are absolutely necessary to connect the several letters of
viii THE PREFACE.
the nuncio to the court of Eome, and the many papers and me- morials which passed in the disputes between that minister and the supreme council ; which he translates faithfully into Latin, on which account this collection seems the more curious. I was allowed the perusal of this work by a noble peer of this kingdom, who, in his travels to Italy and other foreign countries, collected this, with a great many valuable manuscripts of great use in the commonwealth of learning, and which he is very free in commu- nicating for the good of the public. I have had frequent occa- sion of quoting this collection for many particulars which would not otherwise have come to light, as will appear by the references vi thereto in the course of this history.
7 There are several copies of the marquis of Clanricard's me- moirs, containing a series of his letters, proceedings, and reflec- tions upon the orders which he received from the lords justices of Ireland, and the events which happened in that kingdom from Oct. 23, 1641, when the rebellion broke out, to Aug. 30, 1643, when he was going to Sigginstown to assist at the treaty for a cessation. There is little doubt to be made but that he con- tinued to take the same method of digesting his letters and reflections upon other passages of Irish affairs till the end of the troubles ; and I have been assured by gentlemen (particularly by Mr. Nicholas Wogan of Rathcossy) that they had seen a com- plete collection of that nobleman's memoirs. But by some acci- dent or other they are now lost ; at least it is not known where they are to be found ; and all the copies still in being are only of the first volume. The best and probably the original of these is in the possession of the present archbishop of Cashel ; all the letters (as I see) being wrote either in the lord Clanricard's own hand, or that of his secretary, the one interspersed with the other. That which I made use of in this work was commu- nicated to me by the right honourable the earl of Egmont, who in his great humanity supplied me with several other curious papers, and particularly with sir Philip PercivaFs account and defence of the cessation.
8 The duke of Ormond was very free in lending and communi- cating his papers to persons engaged in any public work, wherein they might be of service. When Dr. Nalson was mak- ing the collections which he afterwards published, he was obliged to his grace for his assistance in that work, as he acknowledged in his introduction to the second volume of those collections.
THE PREFACE. ix
This made me curious to inquire what was become of the doc- tor's papers, and finding that they were in the hands of the reverend Dr. Williams, senior fellow of St. John's college in Cambridge, I applied to that learned gentleman for the perusal of such as would be useful for my purpose. They were bound up in about twenty volumes, and a catalogue being taken of those which related to Ireland, and transmitted to me by the reverend Dr. Zachary Gray, rector of Houghton Conquest in Bedfordshire, I was likewise obliged to that worthy gentleman for a transcript of such as I wanted.
9 The duke of Ormondes papers furnished me with ample ac- counts of his conduct in public affairs ; but for the passages of his private life here related, I derive most of them from the pre- sent bishop of Worcester, who lived several years in his grace's vii family, and from a manuscript which sir Robert Southwell left behind him, consisting of about 100 pages in folio, and contain- ing such domestic informations touching the duke's life as he had received from his graced own mouth. It is much to be la- mented that the former of these, with one of the finest pens that any age hath known, and a perfect knowledge of his grace's con- duct, did not write the life of that great and good man. He had once been prevailed with to undertake it, chiefly upon this consideration, that he could continually have recourse to the duke for a fuller information, whenever he met with any intricate or perplexed occurrence, which required a clearer explanation than letters or written memoirs afforded. But sirR. Southwell, com- ing soon after to Cornbury, was desirous to undertake the work himself; to which the bishop readily consented, that gentleman having had the honour of a longer acquaintance with his grace. From the time of this undertaking, sir Robert set himself to draw up relations of the most important passages in the duke's life, which he afterwards read over to his grace at the visits which he made him from time to time at Cornbury, Badminton, and Kingston-hall ; where he used to make a considerable stay, and employ the time in discoursing of those passages. These relations and narratives were imparted to me in the most oblig- ing manner by the right honourable Edward Southwell, esq., secretary of state for the kingdom of Ireland.
10 The death of the duke of Ormond, and the troubles wherein, upon the revolution in 1688, the kingdom of Ireland was for some years involved, interrupted sir R. Southwell in going on
x THE PREFACE.
with the work, all his time being taken up in attending to his private affairs, which suffered exceedingly during those troubles. When that kingdom was recovering its quiet, Dr. William More- ton, dean of Christ-Church in Dublin, and bishop of Kildare, (who had been for some years chaplain to his grace, and was advanced by him to those dignities,) by letters in 1692, pressed sir Robert to resume the work, for which he had himself been making collections, in order to do some justice to the character of his great and good master, (so he styles the duke,) and that the world might not lose the benefit of so illustrious an example of true religion, integrity, loyalty, virtue, and honour. Sir Robert wished for retirement to enable him to go on with so noble an enterprise, from which the very reverence he had for the duke helped to deter him. " But", says he, " at present I am tied to the arts of living, and how to help myself and friends, till our acres after so much trampling have time to look green. I per- viii ceive your lordship hath leisure and passion too for such an enterprise, and surely the field is very large in a long life, and great variety of fortune ; and there seems to be harvest enough for several hands. I wish many would set themselves to collect materials, and to ascertain the bounds of what fell under his conduct or influence, and some to detect his enemies and the foundations of their malice. I think his whole life was a straight line, if ever a man's in the world were so. If the materials were once gathered, then were the true time to think of an architect. In the mean time I wish your lordship all success in what you are attempting that way."
ii The bishop of Kildare made some collections, but never at- tempted to digest them in the method of an history; and sir Robert Southwell being overtaken with age and infirmities, seems never to have resumed the enterprise. The design of writing the duke of Ormond's life being thus left imperfect, it hath been my fate, at this distance of time, and with the helps abovemen- tioned, to execute it in the best manner I was able, and as it is now offered to the view, and submitted to the judgment of the world. I was encouraged to the undertaking by the excellent character which his grace generally bore in the world, and by the particular testimonies which those who knew him best gave of the virtue and integrity of his life and conversation ; which sufficiently secured me from the charge of flattery, if I should attempt the difficult province of giving him those just praises,
THE PREFACE. xi
which could not be denied him without injury to his memory. In order to possess the world with a right notion of his grace's conduct, it was necessary to represent the circumstances of the times, the situation, perplexities, and difficulties of affairs, through which his admirable judgment and unparalleled in- tegrity enabled him, without any other guide or instructions, to steer a course which merited the applause of all good men, and was infinitely to his own honour, as well as the entire satisfaction of his prince. I have therefore from time to time given faithful accounts of the state of affairs in Ireland, as well previous to the rebellion as during the continuance of the war; that the reader might the better judge of the expediency of the measures taken, and of the wisdom of the conduct observed by the duke of Ormond.
12 I had an infinite number of authentic materials for this pur- pose ; which it required no little time and pains to digest. By these I examined the many printed relations and accounts of the affairs of those times; and found them generally full of con- fusion, mistakes, and falsehoods, as well as contradictory to each ix other. They seem calculated to answer the ends of parties in those days, and were published to countenance their measures and advance their respective interests. Nothing was more frequent in the time of the troubles of these kingdoms, and yet nothing can be more amazing now than to see the most formal and particular relations of occurrences that never happened, and of facts which were never acted, confidently published without the least foundation for the story. One defect runs through all the narrations and histories of that age, (and even the noble his- torian, to whom we owe the history of the rebellion, is in too many instances defective in this respect,) that they neglect to specify the date and time of events. It hath cost me no little labour to correct this defect, and to fix exactly the time of such events ; which was the more necessary to be done, not only be- cause in abundance of cases it evidently shews the error and falsehood of several relations which have passed for current by being delivered in general, without those circumstances which would serve to confute them, but also on account of the light which it gives in historical matters; for the order of actions being once settled, the scene of affairs opens naturally to the view, and no event appears wonderful. I may possibly be thought to have been too exact in this respect ; but a writer who in his
xii THE PREFACE.
account of the same affairs takes a liberty to contradict the re- lations of others cannot be excused, if he is not very exact in his own. It is a liberty which I have taken with great freedom, but (as 1 am fully persuaded) with great reason ; and I trust, that whatever other defect be found by critics in this history, nobody will have any cause to complain of want of exactness. I have carried this exactness so far, that though I might have related several passages in apter expressions and a more agree- able manner, I have chosen generally to do it in the very words of the original letters or instruments from whence, they are taken. I have also all along through the course of the troubles referred to the authorities which verify my relations ; though in the latter part of this history, in passages where I had nobody to contra- dict, I have saved myself that trouble, and have assumed the privilege of an historian in resting matters upon his own faith ; though I have as good evidence to support my accounts of affairs in such cases as I have in others, for the proof of which I have made particular references.
13 I have been very particular in my account of the conduct of the marquis of Antrim, and of all passages relating to his trial before the court of claims, and the letter of king Charles II. in his behalf to the commissioners of that court. I am sure I x have been very impartial, and I thought I had been very full upon this subject ; but a pamphlet put into my hands a few days ago makes it necessary for me here to take notice of one par- ticular, much insisted on in that pamphlet, which was printed whilst 1 was in France in the year 1723, and is entitled, A Defence of the Memorial of the Reformation, &c. by Benjamin Bennet. This writer hath been pleased to take notice of a vin- dication of king Charles I from the imputation of being con- cerned in the Irish massacre, (as laid upon him by Mr. Baxter and Dr. Calamy, upon the credit of the story of the marquis of Antrim) which was published in 1714, under the title of The Irish Massacre set in a clear Light ; a title different from what I had given it, and affixed to it by the bookseller without my knowledge. Mr. Bennet, as far as I have observed, does not contradict any one fact which I assert in that vindication, ex- cept in calling Daniel O'Neile an Irish papist, whom I there affirm to be a protestant. My assertion was founded, not only on his enjoying a post in the bedchamber under king Charles I, when no papist could enjoy any, and when his religion would
THE PREFACE. xiii
certainly have been objected to him, if he had been a papist, but also on the testimony of the late Mr. Leasson, then at Bath, who had been comptroller of the post-office from the restoration till after the revolution, and knew him very well. Daniel O'Neile was not only a protestant by profession, but very zealous in his religion, as I see by his letters, (hundreds of which I have read,) and gave better proofs of his inviolable attachment to it than any who asperse him have had opportunities of giving, by his strict adherence to it all the time of the troubles of Ireland, and of his following the king's fortune abroad. He was a man of great capacity, and was excellently qualified for any employment either in the field or cabinet, and could not have failed of a con- siderable post in foreign service, if his religion had not been an obstacle to such preferment, as it was to his being chosen upon Ouen O'Neile's death general of Ulster; that command being (as will be seen in this history) offered him, if he would turn Roman catholic.
14 People that take things upon trust, and believe every idle re- port without taking the pains to examine it, will always fall into such mistakes as Mr. Bennet has made in the case of Daniel O'Neile. But the passage I am particularly concerned to take notice of in his pamphlet relates to a letter of king Charles the First, which (according to Mr. Baxter) " the marquis of Antrim produced in the house of commons of England upon the lord Massareene's prosecution of his cause before that assembly, after xi the court of claims had declared the marquis innocent, and which (it is said) gave him orders for taking up of arms." Mr. Bennet lays a great stress upon this letter, and upon the credit which he imagines is due to Mr. Baxter; but surely Mr. Baxter is not the only person in the world who never took any story upon trust from another. There are many passages in the his- tory of his life which shew him to be a credulous man, and one that did not always examine into facts with the care that ought to be wished. In this, I think, there is no doubt but he is mis- taken, and therefore I charitably judge he took it upon a common hearsay. The only circumstance mentioned about this letter (and if Mr. Baxter had any knowledge of the fact he certainly might have been much more particular) is, that it was produced in par- liament upon lord Massareene's applying to the house of com- mons for relief against the decree of the court of claims in favour of the marquis of Antrim. This lord Massareene was the famous
xiv THE PREFACE.
sir John Clotworthy, who died on the Saturday before Sept. 25, ] 665. The marquis's trial was on Aug. 20, J 663, but there was no occasion for Massareene or the adventurers to appeal to the parliament from the sentence then given, because it was imme- diately superseded and annulled by the king's express orders, as evidently appears in this history, where that affair (without any regard whether it makes for or against what I have said in the vindication abovementioned) is impartially, and perhaps too minutely related. I shall not here offer to produce any other reasons to shew that there was no such letter read in the house of commons, but only assure the world, that some years ago, by the favour of the late Mr. Jodrell, I searched all the journals of that house from the restoration till after A. D. 1670, and could find no entry or mention made of any such letter, nor of the marquis of Antrim's appearing before the commons, nor of the lord Massareene's presenting any petition or bringing the cause before that assembly. And indeed if any such application had been ever made, I should certainly have found some mention of it in lord Aungier's letters to the duke of Ormond, that noble- man being a member of the house of commons of England, a constant attender, scarce ever missing a post in writing to the lord lieutenant, and seldom omitting to speak particularly of lord Massareene's proceedings whilst he was in England. The time when I read through the journals of that house for this purpose was in Christmas holydays, when that great patriot of his country Mr. Hutchinson was drawing up his account of the half-pay officers ; for I met him at the house upon that occasion, xii The paper-office is a repository of papers, not such as are pre- sented to the house of commons, but such as are reposed with the secretaries of state. However, as Dr. Calamy hath been pleased to say that he was informed the original of this letter was once in the paper- office, I took the pains of searching it likewise ; but could find no such letter, though I met with peti- tions to the king in council, and several other papers relating to the marquis of Antrim. I have thought it proper to give the world this account of the issue of these searches, for fear my silence on the subject should be misinterpreted, so as to gain any credit to this story of the letter of king Charles I, which reason- able men will hardly think deserves any.
15 How free king Charles was from that charge which this pre- tended letter is brought to countenance, appeareth clearly enough
THE PREFACE. xv
from the series of his letters to the duke of Ormond already published. I have suppressed none of his majesty's letters, and the earl of Arran having found some few other originals since the volume of letters was published, I have inserted them in the Appendix, making it a point of religion to shew to the world all his correspondence on that subject with a minister who had en- tirely his confidence, that they may be convinced of his innocence by such irrefragable evidences of his undisguised sentiments, in- tentions, instructions, and conduct. The reader will see in this work what were the true causes and motives to the Irish rebel- lion, who had the greatest hand in kindling, spreading, and con- tinuing the flame, and who were the most concerned in the iniquity of that affair. I have related things as I found them, not troubling myself where they pressed ; and if any, or perhaps all parties find themselves disobliged by any relations therein given, I have no apology to make, but that I know nothing upon earth so sacred as truth, and that I would not have taken pen in hand now, nor ever will on any occasion, but to speak it, whom- ever it may affect. Whoever writes an history with views of serving a party may perhaps do a present job for them, but will not please their successors, whilst he doth a lasting disservice to his country. I think I have been impartial in my relations, in which I am sure 1 am supported by good authorities ; and if my own heart hath deceived me in this point, it is in despite of an uncommon care to know it, and of a firm resolution of being impartial.
16 I have had a long scene of iniquity to travel through; but being persuaded that a man ought to reserve all his severity of judgment for his actions, I have been very tender in speaking xii. of others1 failings. I have not affected to take notice of them unnecessarily ; nobody can tell so well as myself what I have omitted to say of the crimes of particular persons : and I am not conscious to myself of having exposed them in any case, but where it was necessary, either to do a justice due to the charac- ter of some injured person, or to clear up some important matter in history. In such cases it is the duty of an historian to speak out and declare the truth, however his inclinations might other- wise lead him to be silent. Mine have been ever strong on the side of humanity, and I have ever hated to speak ill of persons ; so that if I have on some occasions given bad characters or mentioned dishonourable actions of particular persons, it ought
xvi THE PREFACE.
to be ascribed entirely to the sense I have of what is due to truth and justice; and if any body shall judge otherwise, and think fit to complain of the measure of iniquity assigned to any person in the course of this history, I am ready to make up his full account, whenever I shall be properly called upon for that purpose. I have used all my attention and been exceeding care- ful to avoid mistakes ; but if any have crept into this work, not- withstanding all my care, I shall be obliged to any body that hath had opportunities of knowing better, and will take the pains to correct them ; being concerned for nothing so much as for the cause of truth, and detesting nothing more than to be the means of conveying any falsehood down to posterity.
THE INTRODUCTION,
CONTAINING
MEMOIRS OF THE HOUSE OF ORMOND.
FT1HEKE is nothing more difficult than to give an exact ac- JL count of the descent of ancient families, and to trace it up to their original. Time, which in historical matters is often the mother of truth, serves as frequently to baffle the utmost dili- gence in genealogical inquiries. The low state and narrow limits of learning in former ages, barren of learned men; the paucity of writers, and the want of memoirs and records, parti- cularly in this kingdom, which afford us very few till some time after the conquest, and scarce any original charters before, ren- der it generally impracticable to discover the origin and condition of families before that time. The science of heraldry was utterly unknown till after that era ; it was the expeditions made in the 1 2th age to the Holy Land which laid the first foundation of that science. Bodies of men of different countries, and under differ- ent commanders, being assembled into one army, and engaged in the same enterprise, it became necessary for each body to know their chieftain in a day of action, and consequently for that chieftain to distinguish himself by some particular badge, mark, or device, which he wore over his armour, that his troops might by their leader's example be the better encouraged to follow him on to victory, or, in case of a rout, to rally about his person. This was the original of bearing coats of arms, which after some time came to be regulated by certain rules, and to serve for a distinction of noble families, and of the different branches of such families. It was still later before family-names came to be generally used and fixed in these parts of the world. A surname was indeed often given to persons, but yet it did not express or point out any relation between father or son, and ORMOND, VOL. i. c
xviii THE INTRODUCTION.
the several shoots and members of the same common stock. It was in noble families taken sometimes from the colour of their hair, the complexion of the face, some mark in the body, some circumstance in the birth, some part or fashion of their dress, some event in their life or passage in their conduct. Some- times it was taken from the lands which they enjoyed, by which the lords of a seigniory were denominated ; but as the lands often changed owners, a different race came thereby to bear the same name as the first possessor : which serves as frequently to puzzle the case, till the surer guide of records comes in to clear up the point, and remove all uncertainty and confusion: and yet from these we have little or no help till the reign of king John.
s At other times, names were taken from the offices and charges which particular persons enjoyed in the court or service of a prince : and when any ancient family bears a name which is likewise the name of any certain office about a prince, it is by ii antiquaries generally deemed to be taken from their ancestors being possessed of that office. Such was the original of the name of Le Botiller or Butler, by which the noble family of which I am writing hath been distinguished ever since Theobald Walter was made chief butler- of Ireland. The descent of it since the grant of that great dignity to Theobald and his heirs is easy enough to be traced from thence by authentic records ; but before that time we must have recourse to conjecture, being involved in the same obscurities and uncertainties as generally attend the original of families of so great antiquity. There are in manuscript two accounts of the original and descent of this family. One was drawn up by Mr. Rothe, a barrister of law, and council to Thomas earl of Ormond in queen Elizabeth's time, but had the last hand put to it by his son, sir Robert Rothe, who succeeded his father in the same post, and had the inspec- tion of all the family deeds and writings. This was in the hands of sir James Ware, and hath passed with the rest of that learned and judicious antiquary's collections, first, into the hands of Henry late earl of Clarendon, and from thence into those of his grace the duke of Chandos. The other was wrote by William Roberts, Ulvester king of arms in Ireland, who took an infinite deal of pains in compiling it, having examined the registers of several abbeys, and made a thorough search into the records kept in Bermingham's tower in the castle of Dublin, and other
THE INTRODUCTION. xix
repositories ; particularly in his own office, wherein at that time (viz. in 1644) a great many valuable charters and records were preserved. This manuscript is now in the possession of Dr. John Stearn, bishop of Clogher, who has likewise a copy of sir Eobert Rothe's.
3 I find by a letter of John Walsh to the duke of Ormond dated July n, 1665, that sir William Domville, attorney general of Ireland, was then drawing up an exact pedigree and account of the family, of which Mr. Walsh gives the following character : " This," says he, " which the attorney hath in hand, is like to be the noblest thing that any subject in the king's dominions hath or can have, beginning from beyond the time of the Conqueror's coming into England, not grounded upon hearsay or self-seeming knowledge, but upon records recorded, and other good evidences to be cited, with the most memorable acts of all those that went before you." Mr. Walsh adds, that he had been upon the sub- ject himself, and though his own observations went beyond any that had wrote upon it before, yet finding the attorney's evi- dences to speak further, he declined proceeding, and communi- cated his collections to sir W. Domville. This pedigree and account of the family by the attorney general would probably have carried this matter to a greater certainty than for want of it can now be attained. Mr. John Butler, a clergyman beneficed in Northamptonshire, and studious of antiquity and heraldry, having read Mr. Roberts's manuscript beforementioned, and sir William Dugdale's account of the family of Walter, in the first volume of his Baronage, and conversed with the latter on the subject, still maintained that the original surname of the family was not Walter, as those two antiquaries imagined, but Butler. He allows Roberts to be in the right when he made Theobald the first Butler of Ireland, son of Herveus Walter, to be de- scended from the cupbearer of William the Conqueror : but says, that Roberts understanding no more than their books in Ireland could prove, was mistaken in his notion that Theobald's surname was Walter, and that he was called Butler merely from his office. He thinks this mistake the worse, because Roberts himself confesseth, that the additional coat of gules three cups or was given him by king Henry II in token that his ancestors had been cupbearers.
4 That Butler was the original surname of the family he endeavours iii to prove from the Annals of Ireland published by Camden, wherein
xx THE INTRODUCTION.
mention being made of Theobald lord Butler about the year 1200, it is said that he was the son of Walter Butler. Now Theobald was the son of Herveus, and grandchild of Walter, but yet was called his son, because Herveus the father dying before Walter the grandfather, Theobald succeeding his grandsire immediately might easily be mistaken for his son. That he was grandson to Walter, and that the same Walter was called Walter Butler, (this gentleman says,) appears, i. For that the brethren of the game Theobald, who were not lord Butlers of Ireland, and who had no concerns in that kingdom, yet were also called by the surname of Butler. An instance may be given of this, in that Theobald Butler, (nephew of Theobald lord Butler of Ireland,) who married Rohese daughter of Nicholas de Verdon, a great heiress, and gave in his coat armour or a chief indented gules, without the addition of the cups ; shewing thereby that he was descended of Herveus Walter, and yet not of the blood of Theo- bald lord Butler of Ireland. Now this man writing himself Theobald Butler and not Walter, it proves (as this gentleman observes) that Herveus, his grandfather, was properly surnamed Butler, and was called Walter only for some accidental reason ; and as may seem, for that Robert his younger brother assuming the surname of Fitz- Walter, or son of Walter, he being the elder brother, wrote himself Walter without Fitz, intimating, accord- ing to the signification of the name, that he was the chief of the family ; as appears by the coat of arms he assumed upon his being made a baron. 2. Hubert Walter, archbishop of Canter- bury, brother to Theobald Butler of Ireland, and second son of Herveus Walter, possessed certain lands of their said grandfa- ther Walter Butler, as appears by the endowment of the priory of West Dereham in Norfolk by the said Hubert, in which set- tlement the said Walter his grandfather joined. 3. We find by Stow's Chronicle in the nth year of Henry I, that Robert le Butiller was the king's cupbearer, and the king settled upon him the lordship of Baynard's Castle, with all Baynard's lands, upon the said Baynard's forfeiture. The son of this Robert was Walter Butler, as he is called by Mr. Camden, though in the Monasticon he is often called Walter Fitz-Robert, as in those days most men wrote themselves after their father's Christian name, though ordinarily otherwise called. And that Theobald was descended of this Walter Mr. Camden also shews, and so does the bequest of Hubert his brother. But Robert Fitz-
THE INTRODUCTION. xxi
Walter, a younger son by the last wife of old Walter, inherited the title and honour of Baynard's Castle ; because Herveus, the elder brother and his sons, were seized of greater honours other- wise.
5 For these reasons, and upon this footing, Mr. John Butler de- rives the pedigree of the Ormond family from Richard I, (grand- son of Rollo,) duke of Normandy ; who had no son by his wife Emma, but by Gunnora had Richard II, from whom descended William the Conqueror, and by another woman had Godefroy or Geoffry, count of Brionis, who was father to Gislebert guardian to William the Conqueror during his minority. Gislebert was father to Richard earl of Clare, and Baldwin, from whom de- scended the family called de Ripariis earls of Devonshire. Ri- chard had issue five sons, Gilbert, Roger, Walter, Robert, and Richard. From Gilbert descended not only the earls of Clare, but Richard Strongbow, earl of Strigul or Chepstow, who did such great things in Ireland. Roger and Walter died without issue. Robert and Richard the youngest sons of Richard earl of Clare, who was cupbearer in ordinary to the king, used in his lifetime to execute that office for him, and thence as- sumed the surname of Bouteillers, and are mentioned in Dooms- day-book by the name of Robertus le Pincerne in Shropshire, i and Ricardus le Pincerne in Cheshire. This Richard was an abbot, but it seems not till after he had issue ; for from him descend the Butlers of Pulton, as the Butlers of Kent do from them.
6 Robert, after his father's death, became cupbearer to king Henry I ; and to him that prince gave the honour of Baynard's Castle, and the barony of Dunmow in Essex. He married a daughter or sister of Simon de S. Lyz earl of Northampton and Huntingdon, and had issue, Walter his eldest son ; Ralph, who was bred up with earl Simon and lord of Oversley in Warwick- shire, from whom the Botilers of Hertfordshire, of Bidenham in Bedfordshire, and Sudeley Castle are descended ; Robert (bred up by Giffard bishop of Winchester, who was his uncle by the mother's side) from whom descend the Hampshire Butlers ; Alured who held manors under the earl of Moriton, from whom the Butlers of Cornwal claim ; and lastly, Simon estated at Da- ventry in Northamptonshire, and thence assuming the name of that place, which he conveyed to his posterity. Robert wrote himself sometimes Fitz -Richard, sometimes Domino de Dun-
xxii THE INTRODUCTION.
mow, but mostly le Butiller. He was slain in battle, and buried at St. Neot's by his father.
7 Walter the eldest son succeeded his father as cupbearer, and was baron of Baynard's Castle. He wrote himself sometimes Fitz -Robert and Dominus de Dunmow, but was generally called le Butiller. He had three wives ; whereof the first was Avice, a sister of Simon the second earl of Huntingdon, by whom he had issue Herveus his eldest son, Theobald and others, born before he became lord of Dunmow, and therefore not recorded there. His second wife was Maude de Bohun, by whom he had issue Richard. His third was Maude the daughter of Richard Lucy. This Walter lived to the last year of Richard I, and by his last wife had issue Robert, who called himself Fitz- Walter, from whom the Fitzwalters barons of Baynard's Castle de- scended.
8 Herveus was father to Theobald first Butler of Ireland, who founded the abbey of Witheny, which was dedicated in 1205. This Theobald is (in the manuscript quoted by Camden) said to be the son of Walter Butler ; but this was occasioned (as hath been said) by the grandfather's surviving his son Herveus. Hu- bert Walter the archbishop's grant of land to Derham monas- tery in Norfolk was confirmed by his grandfather Walter le Butiller. The younger brothers of Theobald and Hubert also wrote themselves le Butiller, as appears from Theobald the son of one of them (who married Roesia de Verdon) being so styled. Herveus, though surnamed Walter, wrote himself also Butiller, (as his posterity did,) and called himself also Walter, as it should seem, according to the meaning of the word, which in the Saxon language signifies chief ; and answerably thereto assumed for a coat of arms or a chief indented azure ; and to distinguish himself from his half-brother Robert, wrote himself Walter with- out Fitz, to intimate that he was chief before his brother, or the first of the family. He married Maude, daughter of Theo- bald de Valoines, as Ranulph de Glanvil chief justice of England married Bertha her other sister. The two brethren in law lived in perfect friendship, and Ranulph assumed for his coat argent a chief indented azure, as near to that of Herveus as was possible. Herveus was one of the adventurers with his kinsman Richard Strongbow in the expedition into Ireland, and with another Her- veus son of Gilbert de Clare ; from whom this Herveus seems to have had his name, and probably some part of his estate.
THE INTRODUCTION. xxiii
9 Herveus Walter or le Butiller died young, leaving five children : i . Theobald his eldest son, called after the name of his grand- father by the mother's side ; 2. Hubert, named after an uncle of that name in Norfolk; 3. Walter, named after his grandfather Walter le Butiller ; 4. Roger, so called after a great uncle who v died without issue ; and, lastly, Hamo. These five children were all left young to the care and education of Ranulph de Glanvil, whose fatherly kindness Theobald and Hubert in their grants to holy uses acknowledge. Thus doth Mr. Butler state the descent of Theobald the first Butler of Ireland ; but as he doth not men- tion the authorities and proofs upon which he founds his notions, there is no dependance upon such parts of this account as are not supported by records.
10 Sir Robert Rothe makes Theobald, butler of Ireland, his father, to be Walter Fitz-Gilbert, i. e. son of Gilbert Becket, and this seems to be allowed by the late sir Richard Cox, who made some remarks on the pedigree. The antiquities of Ireland in Holinshed's Chronicle, Campian in his Chronicle of Ireland, and Dr. Meara, in his poem called Ormonius, (of which Thomas earl of Ormond is the subject,) all suppose the surname of the family to be Becket, and derive it from Walter Becket a younger bro- ther of Thomas. This is certainly a mistake, and seems to have been occasioned by the ancient tradition, (which is confirmed by an act of parliament in the time of Henry VI,) that the Ormond family were the heirs of Thomas Becket ; which though it were fact, yet it cannot be inferred thence that they were descended from a brother of his, since a descent from a sister might equally entitle them to be his heirs. Sir W. Dugdale is certainly in the right, when he makes Herveus Walter to be father to Theobald ; but he does not go so far as to affirm who was father to Herveus. He quotes the pipe-roll of 3 H. II, to shew that Hubert Walter enjoyed lands in Norfolk ; and asserts that he was succeeded therein by Herveus: but whether Hubert was father, grand- father, uncle, or in any other degree of relation to Herveus, he doth not offer to determine.
1 1 Mr. Roberts, Ulvester king of arms, labours principally to prove that the surname of the family was Walter, and not Becket. He observes, that Thomas Becket's arms were argent 3 Cornish choughs proper, whereas those of Theobald, the first butler of Ireland, were or a chief indented azure : and that none of the family were called by the names of Gilbert, Thomas, or Walter,
xxiv THE INTRODUCTION.
after the Beckets. He shews likewise that Theobald I, after he was butler of Ireland, signed his name Theob. Walter to a charter of king John's, recited in a patent roll of Edw. I, preserved among the antiquissimce liter ce patentee in the rolls of the chancery of Ireland, and granting to the canons of Lanthony the lands of Ballibemmer, &c. Beatrix, daughter to this Theobald, uses Walter or Water as a surname in her grants of lands to the monastery of S. Thomas in Dublin : and indeed all the descend- ants of Theobald still kept up the surname of Walter till the time of their being created earls of Ormond. This he proves undeniably by a great number of records, the two last of which in point of time seem to him the most considerable, because in pleas the pedigree must be set down with great exactness, in order to prove the plaintiff's descent for justifying his claim to the lands in dispute. In such case (he says) it hath always been the custom for the plaintiff to set down the surname of his an- cestor from whom he claims the inheritance, and as carefully to write his own surname in the pleadings ; though in other cases, and particularly in charters and grants, such strict heed hath not been usually taken in the writing of names. The first of these records is a plea roll of 13 Edw. II, long enough to fill twenty pages in folio, wherein Edmund Walter, butler of Ire- land, sets forth his title, as descended from Theobald Walter I, to lands in Je Rath juxta Donnenagh-brock possessed by Robert and W. Bagod. The other is a plea roll in 2 Edw. Ill, wherein James the first earl of Ormond styles himself Jacobus Walter Pincerna Hibernice, and sets forth his descent as in the other roll. In both these records the name is spelt Walter and Water indifferently, variations of that kind being very common in an-vi cient writings and records, and clerks being in those days seldom exact in orthography.
12 He thinks Herveus Walter took that name from some office that he enjoyed, and thus accounts for the reason of the name. Verstegan (in his Antiquities printed at Antwerp 1605, p. 329.) says, that Walter is an ancient name of office, and he that was chief ruler over any of the king's forests was styled the king's Walter, (as the comes forestarum, or great master of all the forests in a kingdom, is in the Saxon or German tongue called Waldtgrave). Hence it might in time become a surname, as Steward, Butler, Marshal, Constable, and the like; of which numberless instances might be given. Camden (in his Remains,
THE INTRODUCTION. xxv
p. 90.) says, Walter signifies a governor or general of an army. This Ulvester thinks very agreeable to Theobald's paternal coat, which was or a chief indented azure, and was perhaps given to his ancestor in remembrance of services done as general or forester. For a chief in heraldry is the most known emblem of a chieftain in arms, and is the second of the nine honourable ordinaries ; and so honourable a bearing, that it hath been an- ciently added to the arms of princes of the blood royal, to dis- tinguish their families ; and also, both in ancient and modern times, it hath been given for an augmentation to the names of commanders-in-chief for service done their sovereign. The crest too of Theobald was of a piece with his arms : for as commanders in confused battles and skirmishes wore crests to distinguish themselves, when their beavers were down and closed, and gene- rally made use of the picture of some bird or beast ; so this noble family bears for its crest a falcon within a plume of feathers. That these arms could not come from any marriage he thinks past a doubt, because it was not the practice of England for children to quarter the arms of their mothers, though heiresses, till after king Edward III quartered the arms of England and France in one shield.
13 He thinks the three cups were an augmentation coat, in memory of some service done by Theobald Walter's ancestors in the office of cupbearer, and not as butler, being properly an emblem or badge of the former office. He takes those offices to be different, because the cupbearer attended the king twice a day at his meals, but the butler of England or Ireland was only to attend the kings at their solemn coronation, and that day to present the king with his first cup of wine ; for which (as his honorarium) he had several pieces of the king's plate. The cupbearer for his service had only a fee or pension of 50^. a year : but the chief butler of England had the castle of Boken- ham and manor of Wimondeham in Norfolk given him by the king, to hold the same to him and his heirs, as being the king's butlers at his coronation. He observes further, to shew the difference of these offices, that Henry II waited on his son at his coronation as chief butler, and he was the first institutor of this office, in- vesting with it William de Albeniaco the first earl of Arundel, who was contemporary with Theobald Walter the first butler of Ireland.
14 What Ulvester here says of this W. de Albeniaco or Albini's
xxvi THE INTRODUCTION.
being the first chief butler of England, differs from sir W. Dugdale, who says, that it was his father of the same name who was made butler by William the Conqueror. Upon the whole, whe- ther the great office of chief butler of England, to assist at a coronation, was instituted sooner or later, it seems pretty evi- dent, in the nature of the thing, that our kings never could be at any time without such an officer as a cupbearer or butler. Whether these offices were one and the same in those times, or no, it is certain there was a great affinity between them, and their names are often confounded. Whether Herveus Walter descended of Gilbert earl of Clare, and of Robert and Walter barons of Baynard's Castle, as Mr. Butler supposeth, Ulvester agrees with him in the notion, that at least some of Herveus's vii ancestors were cupbearers, and the augmentation coat of arms was given on that account. The name in Latin (the language of all deeds and charters at that time) for both these offices was pincerna, which I never knew Englished by any other name than butler; and why Herveus's ancestors might not assume that name, as well as he did that of Walter, from an office, I can see no reason. Nobody will doubt but that the name of Butler arose originally from such an office, and that such office was in the family before the time of Herveus seems well supported by his nephew or cousin Theobald's taking the name of le Butiller. That he did so is evident from the clause roll of 9 H. Ill, m. 3, quoted by sir W. Dugdale in his Baronage, vol. i. p. 472, where- in the king expresseth his desire " that Rohese de Verdun would take to husband this Theobald le Butiller, a branch of the noble family of the Butillers of Ireland, and wrote specially to her, to recommend him for that purpose, and likewise to Nicholas de Verdun her father, earnestly desiring him to persuade her there- to." Now this Theobald, though a near relation to Theobald the first butler of Ireland, yet was not descended from him, and so could not assume the name of Butiller on that account. Theobald II, the eldest son of the first butler of Ireland, was not of age till the sixth of Hen. Ill, and lived till the fifteenth of Edw. I. Whereas this Theobald who married Rohesa de Verdun, was of full age in the fifth of Hen. Ill, as appears from the Testa de Nevil, and the clause roll of that year. He died likewise on the Friday next before the feast of St. Mary Mag- dalen, in 14 H. Ill, and his widow Rohese de Verdun two years afterwards, in 16 H. HI, paid 70 marks for her relief, and not to
THE INTRODUCTION. xxvii
be compelled to marry, as appears from the pipe rolls for com. War. in that year. What is further to be noted with regard to this Theobald is, that though in the king's letters, and the clause- roll of 9 H. Ill, he is called Theobald le Butiller, he is in the last cited records, and in a patent roll of 37 H. Ill, called Theobald Walter ; which induces me to think him rather a grandson than nephew of Herveus Walter. This shews how promiscuously the names of Butiller and Walter were used by the descendants of that Herveus. Theobald's said marriage furnisheth also another instance of the change and alteration of names : for John his son by Rohese took on him the name of de Verdun, which was con- tinued by his son and grandson, both Theobalds, the one con- stable, and the other chief governor of Ireland, and by all his posterity.
15 It may possibly be surmised, that the name of Walter might be taken from the Christian name of some ancestor, it being very common to adopt such Christian names for surnames ; as in the case of the lord Peter, baron of Writtle, and the families of Nicholas, Francis, and the like in England. But wLat persuades me that it was taken from some office that Herveus enjoyed is, that the name of Walter is used as his proper and peculiar title, and so far from being common to his father, that the father was forced to borrow this appellation of his son's, to prevent his own being mistaken for a different person. It is so unusual a thing to distinguish a father by the relation he stands in to a son, that though it was necessary to distinguish him from others of the name of Herveus, who might have lands in those counties, yet some other distinction would have been found out, if Walter had not been an office of dignity, and a title peculiar to the son. There is in the pipe roll commonly said to be 5 Steph. but (as Mr. Madox hath proved in his history of the exchequer) in reality much earlier, and as Mr. Prynne thinks of the 1 8th of Hen. I, an entry in the sheriffs account for Norfolk and Suffolk, in these words : Herveus fitius ffervei reddit compotum de x marcis argenti, ut Jiaberet socam et sacam in terra sua. If the person who paid these ten marks was Hervey Walter, it seems he was not yet distinguished by that surname, probably because he was not ye invested with the office of Walter. If the office was that of chieftain in war, as Camden thinks, Herveus probably had the command of some party that went from England on an ex- pedition to the Holy Land, according to the romantic humour of
xxviii THE INTRODUCTION.
that age. If this office was (as Verstegan supposes) that of forester, and if Herveus Walter was not chief prefect or justiciary of all the forests in England, but only custos or warden of some particular forest, I should conjecture (and in matters of such re- mote antiquity there is little room for any thing but conjecture) that it was the forest of Agmundernes in Lancashire. His father certainly had lands in that county, as appears from the book of the fiefs of the county of Lancaster, B. fo. 43, from whence Mr. Dods worth a transcribed this entry : Lane. Theolaldus Walterus tenet dimidium feodi militis, unde Herveus pater Hervei Walter dedidit Ormo magno cum filia sua Alicia in maritagio quatuor carucatas terra in Rawdecliffe, Thistleton, et Greaol per servitium militare. As Herveus Walter had lands in that county, it is natural enough to suppose he might be made warden of the said forest, and thence take his name. Nor is it a little confirmation to this conjecture, that this very forest, which probably he en- joyed only as warden for life, was afterwards granted in per- petuity or fee to his son Theobald Butler of Ireland. To this purpose is the deed which Mr. Dodsworth b transcribed out of the writings of Mr. Henry Butler of Rawdecliffe in Lancashire, in these words : " Richardus (primus) dedit Theobaldo Waltero totam Agmundernes cum omnibus pertinentiis suis &c. per servitium feod. trium militum pro omni servitio suo, scilicet villam de Preston cum omnibus pertinentiis suis, ac totum dominicum quod ad ipsam villam pertinet, cum omnibus domi- nicis nostris quag ad Agmundernes pertinent, ac totum servitium militum qui tenent de feodo de Agmundernes per servitium militare, et totum servitium libere tenentium de Agmundernes, et totum wapentachiurn de Agmundernes cum omnibus per- tinentiis suis, et totam forestam de Agmundernes, cum tota vena- tione, et cum omnibus placitis de foresta, tenend', &c. Dat. 22 Apr. anno regni nostri quinto."
It is very probable that the Butlers of Rawdecliffe in Lan- cashire descended from a younger son or brother of Herveus Walter; for as the father Herveus gave some lands there to Ormus Magnus, by way of portion with his daughter Alicia, (which for want of issue reverted to the heir at law, Theobald first butler of Ireland,) so either he or his son Herveus Walter might give other lands in that place to a younger son, the an-
a MS. 4144. in Bibliotheca Bodleiana, p. 93. b ib. MS. 4, p. 83, &c.
THE INTRODUCTION. xxix
cestor of that branch of the family. This branch assuming the name of Butler rather than that of Walter, makes it probable that they descended from Herveus the father, rather than from Herveus Walter the son, from whom the name of Walter seems originally to be derived. But the frequent alteration of names in that age, especially of such as are taken from offices, which only come to be fixed in course of time, renders this only con- jectural.
17 The records above mentioned seem to represent it as certain that Herveus was the father of Herveus Walter : and yet nobody who has wrote on the subject seems to have had any notion of such a person ; the reason of which seems to be the constant tradition in the family of their being of the blood of Thomas Becket. This tradition is supported by the parliament roll in 32 H. VI, in which is this record: " Qusedam petitio exhibita fuit domino regi in parliamento prsedicto per commu- nes ex parte Jacobi comitis Wiltes et Ormonde in hsec verba. To the full wise and discreet commons of this present parliament sheweth unto your notable discretions and wisedoms James earl ix of Wiltsheire and Ormonde, that where he is seized in his de- measne as of fee of the mannour of Huckcoate, with the advow- son of the church of Huckcotte to the said manner appertaining, and a croft called the Litulmilne-hamme, with their appur- tenances in the county of Buckingham, the guift and feofment of James late earle of Ormonde, fadre to the said earle of Wilt- sheire, and John Neal Clerk ; and that the said earle of Wilt- sheire, at the reverence of our Lord Jesus Christ, and of his blessed moder our lady S. Mary, and in worship of that glorious martyr S. Thomas, sometyme archbishop of Canterbury, of whose blood the said earl of Wiltsheire his fader, and many of his ancestors are lineally descended, and the which glorious martyr was born of his modir within the ground where now is set the house or hospital of the said martyr, called S. Thomas of Acres, within the city of London, and also for great tenderness, trust, and love, which the said James late earl of Ormonde, (on whom God have mercy,) when he was alive, had unto that devoute and holy place; and also forasmuch as the modir of the said earle of Wilteshire is buried within that holy place, is disposed, agreed, and fully set, for him and his heires, in consideration of the pre- misses, and by the agreement, comfort, and supportation and assent of your full great and notable wisedomes, that John Neal,
xxx THE INTRODUCTION.
now master of the said house or hospital, shall have the said mannour of Huckcote, with the advowson thereto appertaining, and the said croft with their appurtenances, to him and to his successors for evermore, to the intent that he and his successors shall find two priests within the said house or hospital per- petually and daily to pray for the good estate of our sovereign lord the king, and our sovereign lady the queene, and of the said earle of Wiltsheire, and for the soules of our sovereign lord the king, and the queen when they been passed out of this world, and for the soules of the fadir of the said earle of Wiltsheire, and of his modir, and for the soul of the good lady dame Joane Beauchamp, late lady of Bergaveny, grand-dame to the said earle of Wiltsheire, and for the soules of all other his ancestors that been dead, and for the soules of the said earle of Wiltsheire and of his wife and their heyres after their decease ; and for all Christian soules. Which intent and disposition the said earle of Wiltsheire may not performe ne fulfill without your special favour, helpe, and succour to be to him shewed in this behalf, wherefore please it your full great and notable wisedomes to consider the premisses, and to pray the king our sovereign lord, that by the assent of his lords spiritual and temporal in this present parlament assembled, and by the authorite of the same, he will ordeine and establish that the said John Neal, now mas- ter of the said house or hospital, or his successors, may enter into the said mannour of Huckcote with the advowson aforesaid, and the croft with th' appurtenances, to have and to hold the said mannour and th' advowson thereunto appertaining and croft with their appurtenances, to the said master and his successors for evermore, without interruption, impediment, or impeachment of the said earl of Wiltsheire, or of his heires, or any other per- son or persons pretending title to them or to their use, in per- forming the said intention and disposition above rehearsed; provided always that this act, statute, or ordinance shall not exclude ne forbarre none other person or persons claiming or having title or right to the said mannour with the advowson aforesaid and croft with their appurtenances to the use of the said earl of Wiltsheire or of his heirs for the love of God and in way of charitie. Quse quidem petitio parlamento prsedicto lecta, audita et plenius intellecta, eidem petition! de avisamento et assensu praedictis respondebatur sub his verbis, Soit fait come il
THE INTRODUCTION. xxxi
1 8 Pursuant to this notion, in a very large roll, drawn up by the x heralds in the latter end of the reign of king Charles II, finely emblazoned, and preserved among the evidences in the castle of Kilkenny, I find the pedigree of the family thus stated, to the time of the first butler of Ireland.
Thomas filius Theobaldi = Agnes Becket soror Thomae Becket de Heilli, I Archiepiscopi Cantuariensis.
|
Herves Walter = filius Thomae |
= Maude de Valoines. |
|||
|
5 Hamon Fitz Walter, |
4 Roger Fitz Walter, |
3 Walter Fitz 2 ' Walter, |
Fheobald fil. Walteri the first butler of Ireland. |
I Hubert Walter, archbp. of Canterbury. |
19 If this pedigree were that which sir W. Domville drew up out of ancient records, and other evidences as high as the conquest, it would deserve a very great regard ; but I fancy it not to be the same, because it contains no reference to any of those records or evidences which should prove the descent. I see, By letters to the duke of Ormond, that sir W. Dugdale and others in the office of arms were employed upon that subject, but whe- ther the pedigree here quoted be the issue of their searches doth not appear. In that office there is a book of Vincent's, a dif- ferent state of the pedigree, in this manner :
|
TheobaldusdeHely. |
Gilbert Becket. 1 |
|
|
Thomas |
1 1 1 Walter Fitz Theobald = Agnes Mary, Thomas Becket, [abbess of archbishop of Canterbury. Barking. Hubert Walter 1 |
|
|
Theobald, first butler of Ireland. |
Hubert, archbishop of Canterbury. |
20 In this last pedigree there is certainly a mistake in Hubert Walter to be the father of Theobald Walter and Hubert, archbishop of Canterbury, and Walter the son of Theobald de Hely to be the husband of Agnes Becket. There is no historian or record that ever mentions such a person as Walter Fitz Theobald de Hely, and it is evident past all dispute, from the charter of E. Ill, and the act of parliament 23 H. VI, recited in the Monasticon, vol. 2. p. 411 and 412, that Thomas son of Theobald de Helles or Heilli married Agnes Becket, and founded the hospital of St.
xxxii THE INTRODUCTION.
Thomas de Acres in London. It is likewise certain from the charter of Hervey Walter, recited in the same volume of the Monasticon, p. 245, and containing a grant of lands to the priory of Buttel in Suffolk, that Hervey Walter was the father of Theo- bald Walter, and of Hubert, afterwards archbishop of Canter- bury, Walter, Roger, and Hamon, according to the Kilkenny pedigree. This appears likewise from Theobald Walter's char- ters of the foundation of the abbey of Cokersand in Lancashire, (ib. p. 631,) of the convent of Arkelo, in the county of Wicklow, (ib. p. 1025,) and of the abbey of Wotheny, alias Woney, in the county of Limerick in Ireland, (ib. p. 1035,) in all of which char- ters mention is made of Hervey Walter as father, and of Hubert Walter the archbishop as brother to the said Theobald Walter, the first butler of Ireland.
21 The Kilkenny pedigree being thus far justified, the only ques- tion left is, whether Thomas, son of Theobald de Heilli, Hely, or Helles, and husband of Agnes Becket, was really the father of Hervey Walter. The reason why I dispute it arises from its inconsistency, not only with the book of fiefs of the county of xi Lancaster before quoted, where Herveus is positively said to be the father of Hervey Walter, but also with the age of this last. Thomas Becket was killed on Dec. 29, 1170, in the 4<Sth year of his age, so that he was born A.D. 1123. Jerusalem was taken by Godefrey de Bouillon on July 15, 1 099, in the first expedition to the Holy Land. It doth not appear that there were any English in that expedition, and some years passed before any person of note carried any party thither from this kingdom. Among those cavaliers who desired to shew their zeal for religion by adven- tures in the eastern part of the world, Gilbert Becket was one. He was so considerable a person at that time, that when Alberice de Ver was put out of the post of portgrave, or governor of London, (upon which he was created by the empress Maude, earl of Oxfordshire, or of any of the three counties he should choose,) Gilbert a Becket was by king Stephen put into that office, one of the most important in the kingdom, of which that city, not yet incorporated, was the metropolis. He had the good fortune to return alive, after having been a prisoner for a year and a half among the infidels. Whilst he was in captivity, he had been the instrument of converting the daughter of a Saracen commander to the Christian faith, who afterwards making an escape from her friends, came into England, found out Gilbert,
THE INTRODUCTION. xxxiii
was baptized and married to him. Brompton in his Chronicle (ad ann. 1163) says, that Gilbert immediately after his mar- riage made a second voyage to the Holy Land, leaving his wife with child of Thomas Becket, and stayed three years and an half in that country. After his return he had the two daughters before mentioned ; nor is it of any consequence which of them was the elder, since neither of them could be born till the year 1127, and consequently neither could be grandmother to Theo- bald and Hubert Walter.
22 Hervey Walter their father married Maude daughter of Theo- bald de Valoines, as Ranulph de Glanville married Bertha the other daughter of the same Theobald. Hubert Walter, found- ing the abbey of West-Derham in Norfolk, in his charter men- tions Ranulph and Bertha, and then adds qui nos nutrierunt ; which hath furnished a pretence for the notion that Hervey died young, and left his sons Theobald and Hubert to the care of Ranulph de Glanville. But as it was a common thing in those days to put young noblemen under the tuition of such eminent and learned persons as Ranulph de Glanville was, for instruction in their studies, and direction in their education, it was on this account that Theobald and Hubert were bred up with him ; for their father was living long after they came to man's estate. Ranulph de Glanville founded the priory of Buttele in 1171, and afterwards Hervey Walter endowed it with some lands in Wyn- field and Sykebroc in Suffolk, and this charter is attested by Hubert and three other of his sons. Hubert Walter having in the time of Henry II been one of the barons of the exchequer jointly with his uncle Ranulph de Glanville, (who paid a great deference to his judgment and opinion in all cases,) and also dean of York, was by Richard I advanced to the see of Salisbury, and in 1193 made archbishop of Canterbury. He was at the same time chancellor and chief justiciary of England ; and so many charges (though he was really equal to them all, and dis- charged them with a capacity and justice that deserved the highest commendation) exciting the envy of the world, he in i j 95 wrote a letter to the king, mentioned in Parker's Antiqui- tates, desiring leave to resign his civil offices, alleging that he was now senex el valetudinarius. Supposing him to be at this time sixty years old, he must be born in 1135, at which time Agnes Becket could not possibly be above eight years of age, and therefore can never be supposed to be his grandmother. ORMOND, VOL. i. d
xxxiv THE INTRODUCTION.
His brother Theobald was still elder than he, and therefore suc- ceeded to all the estate of their father both in Suffolk and Lan- cashire. Henry II was at Chinon in Touraine, A.D. 1170, andxii there signed a charter for the priory of Coverham in Yorkshire, (Monast. vol. ii. p. 648,) to which Theobald Walter and Ranulph de Glanville were witnesses. At the time of the black book of the exchequer, published by the late Mr. Hearne, (which he sup- poseth to be about the time of the marriage of Maude, daughter of H. II, to Henry duke of Saxony, which was in 1 164,) Theo- bald Walter held Amounderness in Lancashire, by the service of a knight's fee. Hervey Walter his father marrying the elder daughter of Theobald de Valoines, may well be supposed as old as Ranulph de Glanville, who married the other daughter. This Theobald de Valoines in the sheriffs account for Norfolk and Suffolk, in 18 H. I, (of which year Mr. Prynne judged the oldest pipe roll to be,) i. e. A.D. u 17, is said to pay a fine of twenty pounds to the king for a breach of the peace ; and might then have a daughter fit to be married to that Herveus filius Hervei, who in the same rolj is said to pay a like fine for erecting his lands in those counties into manors. Nor do I see any reason why the Hubert Walter mentioned in Dugdale's Baronage to hold lands in Norfolk in 3 H. II, (i.e. at the latter end of 1156 or the following year,) may not be the same Hubert Walter who bought lands in West-Derham of Geoffrey Fitz Geoffrey, and settled them on the priory of Buttele, which he founded. But what is here mentioned shews very plainly that Thomas Fitz Theobald de Helles, Heilli, or Hely, could not be the grandfather of Theobald Walter the first butler of Ireland. 23 That descent being disallowed, it will be difficult if not im- practicable to account for the lineal descent of the Ormond family from the sister of Thomas Becket, which was an old tra- dition in the family, and so generally allowed that it procured at last the authority of parliament for its support. Soon after the archbishop's death, Thomas son of Theobald de Hely or Heilli, and his wife Agnes, founded the hospital of S. Thomas de Acres, and gave to it the house where Gilbert Becket lived, and where Thomas Becket his son was born, with some lands thereto adjoining. The question hence arising is, who was this Theobald de Hely, or Heilli, or Helles ? a question not easy to be solved, because no mention is made of him by any of our historians. This however is certain, (as will appear soon,) that he was a
THE INTRODUCTION. xxxv
person concerned in the conquest of Ireland, and had a great tract of country given him by Henry II, for his services in that kingdom; so that he was living in A.D. 1171, when that king went over with an army thither. For this reason I have been inclined to think him no other than Theobald Walter the first butler of Ireland, who might not take upon him the name of Walter as long as his father lived, but chose rather to de- nominate himself from the country whereof he was lord, and which being in those days known by the name of Hely or Heilli, contained several baronies in Tipperary and the adjoining coun- ties, now distinguished by the names of Ely O'Garthy, Ely O'Carrol, &c. It was usual for the great barons of that age to marry their eldest sons very young, for fear they should (in case of any fatal accident attending themselves) fall into the king's hands, as his wards, and be disposed of in marriage to great dis- advantage. It is natural to think that Hervey Walter took the same method ; and it is scarce credible that his eldest son Theo- bald should not be married till he espoused Maude Vavassour at the latter end of the reign of Richard I, i.e. above twenty years after he had been chief butler of Ireland, and wThen he was at least as much an old man as his brother Hubert. Theobald had by this marriage Theobald II, who was not of age till A.D. 1321.
24 It being so natural to think that Theobald Walter had been married to a former wife, I imagined that by her he might have that Thomas who is styled Fitz Theobald de Hely or Heilli, who married Agnes Becket, and founded the hospital of S. Thomas xiii de Acres in London, where Mercers1 chapel now stands ; and that Thomas dying (as is generally supposed) without issue, all his estate and effects, (and particularly the famous horn of Thomas Becket, which was so religiously preserved in the Or- mond family,) might thereby fall to his father or to his half- brother Theobald II. I met with several things that seemed to flatter this notion, particularly in the chartulary or register of grants made to the famous abbey of S. Thomas, commonly called Thomas Court, in Dublin. This monastery was built 1177, by William Fitz Adelm, chief governor of Ireland, by the command
of king Henry II, for canons of the order of St. Victor, in the presence of Vivianus, presbyter cardinal the pope's legate, Law- rence, archbishop of Dublin, and several others.
25 In this chartulary there are several grants made to that mo- nastery by Beatrix Walter, of lands, churches, and advowsons in
xxxvi THE INTRODUCTION.
the land of Hely or Heilli, which Theobald Walter had given with her in marriage to Thomas de Hereford. The portion given with her was no small one ; it appearing from these chart- ers to contain ten knight's fees ; besides which, her husband held also fifteen knight's fees more in the same land of Hely under Theobald Walter, whom he acknowledgeth for his lord. Thomas de Hereford confirming his wife's grants, added thereto the tithes, advowsons, and ecclesiastical profits and benefices upon those 15 fees which he thus held. Thomas died without issue, and Beatrix afterwards married sir Hugh Purcel, who gave the church of Lochmy to the same monastery. There is likewise in the same register a grant of Roger Poer, whereby he conveys to the said convent all the churches upon his estate in the fourth part of a cantred or hundred, which he held of his lord Theobald Walter in Hely. This, with the eleven chart- ers (for there are no fewer) of Beatrix Walter, and her first husband Thomas de Hereford, shew undeniably that Theobald Walter was lord of Hely or Heilli, and make it probable there was some affinity at least in the case, to produce that extraordi- nary regard which this lady manifested to a monastery founded in honour of Thomas Becket. It appears likewise from these charters, that Theobald Walter had married his daughter Bea- trix in his lifetime ; and as he died in 1 206, his son by Maude Vavasour being then only five or six years old, it is the more likely that he had Beatrix by a former wife. The lands given with her in marriage to Thomas de Hereford, ought, by the terms of the settlement, for want of issue of their bodies, to re- vert to her father and his heirs : yet sir Hugh Purcel her second husband kept possession of several ploughlands in Corkytyn, Dro- milchi, Caneris, and Gertnecloyth. This occasioned a suit for those lands, which Theobald le Botiller, great grandson to Theobald Walter, claimed as his heir, setting forth the deed of settlement and his own descent, as is contained in a plea roll 24 E. I. m. 68, preserved among other records in Bermingham's tower. Purcel pleaded that the lands in dispute had been re- leased by Theobald Walter to sir Hugh Purcel his grandfather, reciting the deed totidem verbis ; the genuineness whereof was denied by Theobald le Botiller ; and upon that point they came to an issue.
26 Theobald Walter himself was before his death a benefactor to the said monastery, which Henry II had founded to expiate the
THE INTRODUCTION. xxxvii
murder of Thomas Becket. He granted to it the church of Ardmulchan, with all the chapels, tithes, profits, and benefices thereto belonging. In this deed he mentions his brother Hu- bert, archbishop of Canterbury, by name, and it is attested by Simon bishop of Meath, William and David bishops of Glende- lach and Waterford, Myler Fitz Henry then lord justice of Ire- land, and several others. Now Simon Rochfort was created bishop of Meath inn 94, and sat near 30 years in that see ; Myler Fitz Henry was made justice of Ireland in the first of xiv king John, and continued so till 1210, when John Gray, bishop of Norwich, succeeded him. David bishop of Waterford was a kinsman to Myler, and consecrated in 1204: and Theobald Walter dying in 1206, this charter seems to have been made in the year before his death. It is probable that the grants of Bea- trix Walter to the same abbey were prior to this in point of time, ladies generally being early and forward in their zeal in the fashion of charity or devotion which prevails in their time ; for charity is so much influenced by fashion, that it hath been constantly observed in all countries, with regard to the different orders of religious, that more benefactions have been always made to them within 30 or 40 years after their institution, than have been made in 300 or 400 years afterwards. Simon bi- shop of Meath is the only bishop who attests the charters of Beatrix ; but her husband Thomas de Hereford's confirmatory and subsequent charters are attested not only by him, but also one of them by Simon, and another by William, bishop of Glen- delach. This see of Glendelach contained almost all the country about Dublin, so that the diocese of the archbishop of this city scarce extended beyond the walls of the place. This was found inconvenient by John Papiron the pope's legate, who, (as sir James Ware in his account of the archbishops of Dublin says,) ordered Glendelach to be annexed to the see of Dublin. It was accordingly so annexed A.D. 1214, when William Piro the last bishop of that see died. Hence it necessarily follows that the grants of Beatrix Walter to the abbey of S. Thomas were made between A.D. 1 194, when Simon Rochfort was made bishop of Meath, and 1204, when William Piro attested the charter of Theobald Walter ; because one of her husband's confirmations of her grants was attested by Simon bishop of Glendelach, pre- decessor to the said William. 27 What hath been observed with regard to these charters,
xxxviii THE INTRODUCTION.
(which are to be found in the register of the abbey of Thomas Court, formerly in sir James Ware's, and now in his grace the duke of Chandos's library,) shews sufficiently that Theobald Walter, the first butler of Ireland, was lord of the country called Hely or Heilli, and might thence, at least whilst his father lived, be very properly styled Theobald de Hely or Heilli ; and that Beatrix Walter, who made the beforementioned grants to the monastery of S. Thomas, (before the birth of her brother Theo- bald II,) was Theobald's daughter by a former wife. Hence I was ready to conclude that Thomas Fitz Theobald de Helles or Hely (who married Agnes Becket) was the son of Theobald Walter by his first wife, mother of Beatrix aforesaid ; and if this Thomas had died without issue, his father, or brother by the half blood succeeding to his estate, their descendants might in process of time be easily mistaken to be of the blood of Tho- mas Becket, as descended from his sister Agnes. But whilst I was entertaining myself with this notion, which the records above quoted seem to flatter, I was informed of other records, which puzzle the matter, and raise up new difficulties. There is in the herald's office a book in the handwriting of Glover, con- taining among other things several transcripts from the register- book of the convent of Bermondsey. Of these, one runs in these words : Agnes soror beati Thomce Martyris in viduitate mea dedi Jiospitali sancti salvatoris de Bermondsey decem solidatos redditus, fyc. Teste Theobaldo milite NEPOTE beati Thomce Martyris. In the next instrument renewing this grant she calls this Theobald (who was witness to the other) her heir : and then follows a confirmation of the grant by the same Theobald, who styles him- self Theobald de Halles. It is evident from hence that Agnes Becket survived her husband Thomas, and Theobald de Halles being called her heir, and being also nephew to Thomas Becket, was probably her son ; though that relation be not expressly mentioned, because of the fondness at that time for being related to that archbishop. This name, here spelt Halles or Helles, is xv by Stow in his Survey of London written Heilli, the name of the territory belonging to Theobald Walter in Ireland, and which in the records of that country is spelt indifferently either Heilli or Hely. So that unless this Theobald the heir of Agnes died without issue, I do not see how the land of Heilli could come to Theobald Walter and his heirs ; or how there could be any pre- tence of affinity between the Ormond family and Thomas Becket.
THE INTRODUCTION. xxxix
Hervey Walter might possibly have a younger brother named Theobald, who might have the land of Heilli given him at the conquest of Ireland, and his issue failing the land might descend to Theobald Walter as his heir at law. It is certain that Henry II, after the murder of T. Becket, to clear himself from either ordering or approving of that murder, was ready to em- brace all opportunities of shewing kindness to his relations ; and Ranulph de Glanville, who went over to Ireland with king John when he was earl of Moreton, might be instrumental in procur- ing grants to his brother Hervey Walter's relations, especially if he had any so near as a brother, for whom he could not but wish a very honourable provision. It is very probable that Herveus, the father of Hervey Walter, might have other chil- dren younger than he ; and I find William son of Herveus was high-sheriff of Norfolk and Suffolk from the 32d of Henry II, to the 2d of Richard I, and in the pipe roll of 15 H. II. for Salope- «cire, this William son of Herveus accounted for ^il. in Hag. de dono Gilberti de Gand tempore regis Stephani, as William de Va- loines did for 40^. in Staness"1 de dono ejusdem Gilberti tempore ejusdem regis. I find also in the pipe roll for Norfolk and Suffolk in 10 Rich. I, this entry, Osbertus filius Harvei reddit compotum de xx 1. pro ducenda in uxorem Margareta de Ria per gratiam do- mini reals. Herveus might also have another son settled in
«7 O
Ireland, but whether he had or no, and whether Theobald de Heilli or Hely was either his son or was Theobald Walter himself, must be left to conjecture. I have here offered my rea- sons for the last notion ; and they prove at least that Theobald Walter was allied by consanguinity to Thomas Fitz Theobald de Heilli, whose lands in Heilli he enjoyed. And certainly there must be some very particular reason for the Christian name of Theobald being continued so many generations in the family, being always given to the heirs male of it ; and perhaps it would have been so longer, if the last Theobald had not died without issue, so that Edmund Walter, or le Botiller, earl of Carrick, who was not born heir to the estate, succeeded on his brother's death. I now come to what seems to be conveyed to us with more certainty from records touching the descent of this family. 28 Herveus the father of Herveus Walter probably came over with William the Conqueror, and had large possessions in Nor- folk, Suffolk, and Lancashire. In the pipe roll commonly called 5 Steph., but certainly some years older, is this entry, Herveus
xl THE INTRODUCTION.
filius Hervei reddit compotum de decem marcis, ut liaberet socam et sacam in terra sua. I take this Herveus the son to be Hervey Walter, so called before he was distinguished by the surname of Walter ; after which it helped to distinguish his father ; as appears from the record before quoted out of the book of fiefs of the county of Lancaster, whereby Herveus the father of Herveus Walter gave to Ormus Magnus, with his daughter Alicia in marriage, four plough-lands in Bawdecliife, Thistleton, et Greaol. These lands so given lay in Amoundernes, and upon failure of the descendants of that marriage fell to Theobald Walter as heir at law. Whether this Herveus the father be the same person, or the son of that Herveus who in Domesday-book is mentioned as one that held lands in capite of the king in Norfolk and Suffolk, which his estate lying in those counties would in- cline one to think ; or whether he was that Herveus mentioned in the Monasticon, torn. i. p. 246, as a younger son of Gilbert de Tunbridge or de Clare, who might possibly settle him inxvi Norfolk where he had lands ; which comes near to Mr. Butler's derivation of the pedigree, and flatters Mr. Roberta's notion, that the cups were added to the family arms, to shew that some of Theobald Walter's ancestors had been cupbearers ; a notion not a little countenanced by an old tradition in the family, (that Theobald Walter descended from one who was cupbearer to the Conqueror,) mentioned in an ancient red book of records relating to the family, which I have seen quoted by Mr. Dods- worth and sir William Dugdale with great deference to its au- thority, and which was at last, by the first duke of Ormondes lending it with too little reserve, lost, with many other valuable papers in the same manner, or whether he was some different person from either of these, must be left to conjecture.
29 Herveus Walter married Maude eldest daughter of Theobald de Valoines : and by her had issue, (as hath been said,) Theobald the first butler of Ireland, Hubert archbishop of Canterbury, Walter, Roger, and Hamon. He was living after the year 1171, when the priory of Buttele was founded by Ranulph de Glan- vville ; and died probably before the third of Richard I, because in that year his son Theobald Walter paid money to the crown for lands at Brusyard in Suffolk; and in the sixth of that king was high-sheriff of Lancashire, and in possession of all the family estate in that county.
30 Theobald Walter had attended the king in his expedition into
THE INTRODUCTION. xli
France, when that prince came to an agreement with the king of France upon the subject of Thomas Becket. This agreement was made in Totiraine, in the summer of A. D. 1170; and his majesty returning from thence in the year following, Theobald attended him in his expedition into Ireland, when he received the submission of Roderick king of Connaght, and all the little princes of that country. His majesty, in consideration of his services, gave Theobald very large possessions in that kingdom, which this nobleman afterwards made the place of his residence. The king likewise, as a further mark of his favour, conferred upon him the butlership of Ireland : this I take to be done in A. D. 1177, at the time that he gave his son John the dominion of Ireland, erected other great offices, and divided the kingdom among his officers, assigning to each special services. Some time after this (as Mr. Roberts, who refers to the patent, says) the king made Theobald another grant of the prisage of wines, to enable him and his heirs the better to support the dignity of that office. By this grant, Theobald had two tun of wine out of every ship which broke bulk in any of the trading ports of Ire- land, and wras loaded with eighteen tun of that commodity ; and proportionably for a lesser quantity, if it amounted to nine tun. This grant of the prisage, according to the custom of those days, when the royal prerogative ran high, was ex abundanti cautela, renewed at different times, and hath been constantly en- joyed by the Ormond family to these days. It was a very valu- able as well as honourable grant ; and nothing more is needful to set forth the value of it, than to observe, that I find by the accounts of it, when the widow of Thomas earl of Ormond en- joyed part of the revenue thence arising, as her thirds, (which occasioned the accounts to be more regularly kept,) the Irish merchants, before 1641, in the infancy of the trade of Ireland, took a lease of them at the rent of 26ool. a year. 31 There is in the rolls of chancery in Ireland, among the anti- quissimcE liters, patentes et concessiones, a patent roll of king Ed- ward I, wherein is recited a charter of king John, then earl of Moreton, in his father's lifetime. This charter containeth a grant to the canons of Lantony of the lands of Ballibemmer and other estates, and was attested by Theobald Walter as the se- cond witness ; the churchmen being always the first in the order of subscribers. I take this charter to be signed in 1 1 85, when king John went into Ireland with Ranulph de Glanville and Gi- xvii
xlii THE INTRODUCTION.
raldus Cambrensis in his company. This last has wrote a short account of the affairs of Ireland at that time ; and in it takes notice of an action near Cork, wherein Dermond Maccarty, prince of Desmond, (who a little before, under the pretence of a treaty, had got his own eldest son into his power, and chopped off his head,) was routed by Theobald Walter, and slain, with most of his party.
32 In defect of what historians might say of this first butler of Ireland, it may not be amiss to recite two charters of his under seal, which may probably appear curious to all lovers of anti- quity. The first of these containeth a benefaction to the abbey of Furnesse in Lancashire, made in king Richard"^ time, and running in these words : " Omnibus sanctce matris ecclesicefiliis tarn presentibus quamfuturis, Theobaldus Walterus pincerna Hybernie salutem. Sciatis me pro Dei amore et beate Domini genetricis Ma- rie, et pro anima domini mei H. regis Anglie, et Ricardi regis filii ejus, et pro salute domini mei Johannis comitis Moreton et domini Hibernie, et pro salute H.fratris mei Cantuar'archiepiscopi, et pro anima cari mei Ranulphi de Glanville, et pro anima Hervei Walter patris mei, et pro anima Matildis de Valoines matris mee, et pro salute anime mee, et pro salute Matildis sponse mee, et pro salute animarum omnium amicorum et antecessorum et successorum meorum dedisse et concessisse, et hac presenti carta mea confir- masse in puram et perpetuam eleemosinam Deo et sancte Marie, et abbati, et monachis qui exierunt de Furneis in cantredo meo de Woednicachelan, et Woednisfergan totum thuedum de Wo- ednifichwith in quo villa de Clonken sita est, cum tota medietate atque de Molcerne in quantum prsedictus thuedus se extendit super prsedictam aquam de Molcerne per omnes rationabiles di- visas suas, cum omnibus pertinentiis suis, &c. Hiis testibus Philippo de Wirecestre, Hamone de Valoines, Gaufrido filio Ro- berti, Willelmo de Burgo, Ric" Tirel, Ric1 de sancto Michaele, Moricio fil. Moricii, Tilleberto de Kentewell, Waltero de Kente- well, Adam de Rachlesden, Willelmo fil. Martini Amaturi de Belfago, Jordano de Lusctf Radulpho de Sancto Patricio, Thoma de Kentewell, Ricardo de Waleton, Willelmo de Blie, Jordano fil. Jordani, Ricardo Clerico, Ranulpho Clerico, Radulpho Clerico de Tyrmi, Johanne de Rupe, et multis aliis." The seal affixed to this charter is of green wax, on which is impressed the figure of a cavalier on horseback, in the usual method, with this in- scription, Sigillum Theobaldi Walteri. This original charter,
THE INTRODUCTION. xliii
the seal of which deserves to be engraved, is to be found among the records of the duchy court of Lancaster, kept in GrayVInn, in the 55th box of deeds. And in the same office, in the 5<Dth box, is another deed with the like seal, made by the same Theo- bald, and mentioning, as the other, the kings Henry II and Richard I, John earl of Moreton, and his brother Hubert arch- bishop of Canterbury.
33 The other charter of this Theobald's, which I proposed to insert, is a grant to his town of Gowran, in the county of Kil- kenny, expressed in these words : " Sciant presentes et futuri, quod ego Theobaldus Walter Pincerna Hibernie dedi concessi, et hac presenti carta mea confirmavi liberis Burgensibus meis de Baligaueran in liberam communiam totam ruffam moram meam, quam habui in orientali parte de Baligaueran, sicut divise et mete existere debent inter terrain de Baligaueran et terram do- mini episcopi Lechlinensis, et totum meum Corrach Ockyrdonan, et totam terram meam quam habui jacentem inter burgagia de Baligaueran et terram quondam Ricardi Pincerne ex mea parte et inter prsedict1 burgagia et terram domini episcopi Ossoriensis de Taschochyn, et inter praedicta burgagia et terram de Kilpo- bell, sicut divise et mete existere debent, cum pertinentiis suis, Habend1 et tenend" de me et heredibus meis sibi et heredibus suis vel suis assignatis in perpetuum cum omnibus libertatibus xviii et liberis consuetudinibus ad dictam terram et moram et Corrach ratione libere communie spectantibus, reddendo inde annuatim mihi et heredibus meis, ipsi Burgenses mei et heredes sui vel sui assignati, decem marcas argenti, viz. unam medietatem ad festum Sancti Michaelis, et aliam medietatem ad Pasch" pro omni ser- vitio exactione et demanda seculari. Et ego predictus Theo- baldus et heredes mei predict' terram et Corrach et moram cum suis pertinentiis sicut dictum est predictis Burgensibus et here- dibus suis vel suis assignatis per predictum redditum contra omnes gentes warrantizabimus in perpetuum. In cujus rei tes- timonium presenti carte sigillum meum apposui. Hiis testibus domino Hugone Purcell, domino Thoma de Kentewell, domino Riso Beket, domino Willelmo Wa...aill, Rogero de Panbroch, Alano de Bath, Davide filio Guelis, Rad° Coco, domino Galfrido de Coilly, Roberto Talbot, Johanne de Duncona clerico et aliis." There is affixed to the deed a very fair seal of green wax, the impression on the shield is a chief indented, being the paternal coat of arms of Walter ; and on each side a cup, to denote the
xliv THE INTRODUCTION.
office of butler. About the verge of the seal is Sigittum Theo- baldi Walteri Pincerna Hibernie : on the other side is a small seal with this inscription, Sigillum Secref.
34 There is among the patent rolls in the Tower one of the 5th of Rich. I, dated April 22, wherein he grants to this Theobald Walter and his heirs all Ay mon denies, to be held by the service of three knight's fees, the town of Preston, and the lordship and wapentake of Aymondernes. This contained all the country be- tween the rivers Eibble and Coker, which in William the Con- queror's time had in it sixteen villages, the rest of it (at the time of taking the survey in Domesday-book) lying waste, but now improved, and taking up almost half Lancashire. This country descended to Theobald Walter by inheritance from his ancestors, as is evident from the pipe roll hereafter quoted, so that this grant of king Richard's was only a confirmation of his former title after his father's death, a practice very usual in those times. It was probably between this time and the death of king Richard that Theobald Walter founded the monastery of Cokersand in that county, and gave the benefaction afore- mentioned to the abbey of Furnesse. For neither he nor Philip de Wircester, who was a witness to this benefaction, were fortu- nate enough to be in the good graces of that prince's successor : and Hoveden says, that king John, soon after his accession to the throne, in the year 1200, sold for 4000 marks to William Braosa all the lands of Philip de Worcester and all the lands of Theobald Walter in Ireland. But Philip escaping from the king returned into Ireland by the way of Scotland, and recovered his land by force of arms : and Theobald, by the assistance of his brother Hubert archbishop of Canterbury, compounded the matter with W. de Braosa, and redeemed his lands by the pay- ment of 500 marks. The original deeds of this redemption or purchase are still preserved among the evidences in the castle of Kilkenny, where, in the press of original charters and instru- ments, I have read a deed wherein " William de Braosa, with the consent of William de Braosa, his son and heir, by his charter dated at Lincoln on the Friday after the Epiphany, in the pre- sence of king John, and in the second year of his reign, grants and confirms to Theobald Fitz Walter and his heirs five can- treds and an half in Munster, viz. the bin-rough of Kildelo with the half cantred called Truoheked, in which the said burrough lieth, the cantreds of Ely Karvel, Elyhokogarthi, Owurmun,
THE INTRODUCTION. xlv
Areth, and Wetheni, and also Owetheni-hokathelan and Ovvethe- ni-hoiffernan ; which said five cantreds and an half Henry king of England gave to Philip de Braosa uncle of the said William the father, and king John, son of the said Henry, afterwards rendered and gave to the said William de Braosa and his heirs ; which xix said five cantreds and an half, with the donation of the parochial churches, with sac, soc, thol, theam, infangenetheof, and judgment or trial by water ordeal or fire ordeal, and trial by duel or com- bat, the said Theobald Fitz Walter and his heirs shall hold from the said William de Braosa and his heirs for ever by the service of 22 knight's fees." The like grants were made by William de Braosa the son, by whom the lands were at last absolutely alien- ated, and the supreme dominion released ; as appears from the original deeds under seal marked by the numbers 13, 21, 28, 35, 41, and 42, in the 2d and 3d boxes in that press. That these were lands originally granted to Theobald Walter appears evi- dently from the charter under seal still to be seen in the same press, and marked N°. 4 ; whereby John, lord of Ireland and son of the king of England, by his charter made at Water- ford, infeofs Ranulph de Glanville and Theobald Fitz Walter of five cantreds and an half in the land of Limerick, viz. the bur- rough of Kildalou with the half cantred called Truoheked Me- leth, wherein the said burrough is situated, and the cantreds of Elikarvel, Eli-Ochgardi, Euermund, Aros and Woedene, and Wo- edene-occadelon and Woedene-oidernan, with their appurtenances, and the donations of parochial churches which now are or here- after shall be therein, to be held by them and their heirs, by the service of 22 knight's fees, with sac, soc, thol, theam, infangenethef, and judgment or trial of water and iron, duel and combat ; ex- cepting the donations of bishoprics and abbeys, and the pleas and dignities which belong to the crown. Though some of the names of places be here differently spelt, it is evident this grant contain- ed the same lands which were afterwards purchased again of William de Braosa.
35 There is in the fourth box of that press a like original charter, marked N°. 52, and under seal ; which serves to shew the defect- iveness of the accounts we have of the succession of Irish bishops, even in the see of Dublin, which of all others was best known to the English. It is a grant made by Richard archbishop of Dub- lin, with the consent of the chapters of the Holy Trinity and S. Patrick's in Dublin, to Theobald Fitz Walter butler of Ireland,
xlvi THE INTRODUCTION.
and his heirs, of the lands of Inchemeholmoe, Kilpoch, Kylinewy, Stachmoyl, Voshehan, Kylcarnewy, Athtrohan, Fannenern, Creachan, Roslayni, Kylcassel, Kylmediske, Karncochel, Ky, Thalchlo . . . nay, Balimoyl and Auenachrin, with the churches, chapels, advowsons, and all liberties; yielding to the archbi- shop and his successors two marks of silver yearly, and to the church of Holy Trinity in Dublin two pounds of wax at Easter, and to the church of St. Patrick's two pounds more for all service and demand. This charter seems plainly to be made to the first butler of Ireland, and yet in sir James Ware's cata- logue of the bishops of Dublin, from the time that see was first erected into an archbishopric (which was in 1152) till Richard de Ferings, who was named by the pope, and consecrated in the middle of A. D. 1299, there never was a prelate of the name of Richard sat in it : and yet Theobald, the last of the name butler of Ireland, died in the beginning of that year before Richard de Ferings was consecrated.
36 Whatever favour king John had shewed to Theobald Walter seems to be owing to the influence of Ranulph de Glanville, or to the express directions of his father king Henry. Thus by an original charter marked N°. i. in the press beforementioned, John, (by the style of) son of Henry king of England and lord of Ire- land, " gives and confirms, by and with the consent of his father, to Theobald Fitz Walter the castle and town of Arclogh, with all the lands and appurtenances thereto belonging, to hold to him and his heirs by the service of one knight's fee." Yet this seems afterwards to have been taken from him by king John ; for I find in the same press an original deed, N°. 72, wherein " William Mareschal earl of Pembroke grants to Theobald Fitz xx Walter and his heirs the town and castle of Arklou, with ap- purtenances, by the service of one knight's fee ; the whole land of Mach-alerus by the service of four knights, and the town of Tholach in Ossory, with the cantred and appurtenances thereto belonging, by the service of four knights, &c." The witnesses to the charter were, the countess Isabel, wife to W. Mareschal, (to whom king Richard had given her in marriage,) Geoffrey Fitz Robert, John de Erley, Gilbert de Kentewell, and others. Whether this power of resuming grants at their pleasure be- longed to the crown at that time, king John thought fit to exer- cise it in the case of Theobald ; though I do not find that he exerted it with regard to his brother Hubert Fitz Walter arch-
THE INTRODUCTION. xlvii
bishop of Canterbury, to whom, whilst dean of York, he had by a charter (preserved with the others here quoted and marked N°. i j .) granted the town of Lusche to be held to him and his heirs by the service of half a knight's fee, with all its appurte- nances in churches and chapels, wood and plain, meadow and pasture, waters and mills, parks and ponds, fishing and hunting^ ways and paths, forests and warrens, with all seignorial rights, (particularly the judgment of water and fire, and duel, pytte and gallows, which last words signify jurisdiction of trying thieves, and of punishing the men by hanging and the women by drown- ing,) excepting still the pleas of the crown.
37 Theobald Walter had not only large possessions in Ireland, but in England too ; where he was put into various employ- ments ; accounting in the first of king Richard, according to the pipe roll of that year, for Ixxii/. vis. \md. of the scutage of the knights of the honour of Lancaster, and in the ninth of that king, being joined in commission with Geoffrey Fitz Piers, (then chief justiciary of England, and who had the greatest sway and power of any man in the kingdom, and was soon after made earl of Essex,) to lay a talliage upon Colchester, &c. In his time the great barons of the kingdom were generally sheriffs of coun- ties, and accordingly in the pipe roll of 6 Rich. I. Theobald Walter accounts as sheriff of Lancashire for i ool. of the farm of Lancaster for half a year. He continued in that office all the rest of king Richard's reign, and for some time in that of king John, executing it by deputies, the first two years accounting by Benedict Gervet, the third by Robert Vavasour, and in the last of the former of those kings, and the first year of the latter by Nicholas Pincerna, or le Botiller. Robert Vavasour seems, when he acted as deputy in 8 R. I. to have been father-in-law to Theobald, and possibly Nicolas Pincerna might be some relation of his. One gentleman of this name had a considerable estate in that county; for in the pipe roll 8 R.I. is this entry: " Willel- mus Pincerna reddit compotum xii marc ne tramfretet in tertio exercitu Norman, post reditum regis ab Alemannia, et pro scu- tagio suo de feod1 vi. militum quse tenet de honore LancastrV1 There is another in the roll of 3 Johan. in these words, Willel- mus Pincerna r. c. de xxx marcis pro feodo viii militum ; and in that of 4 Johan. Willelmus Pincerna r. c. de xvi m. pro scutagio viii militum. Nicolaus Pincerna, who accounted for Theobald Walter, seems to be settled in that county ; for when he was no
xlviii THE INTEODUCTION.
Conger deputy, the sheriff of Lancashire, in 3 John, accounts for ten marks, " de Alano fiT Alani pro habenda seisina terre de Penberton, et pro relevio illius terre, et pro habendo recto ver- sus Nicolaum Pincernam." Whether these Butlers of Lancashire were a younger branch of the first chief butler of Ireland's family, is not at this distance of time easy to be ascertained : but as Rawdecliffe and Thistleton, where they were seated, lay in Amoundernes, and appear by a record before quoted to have belonged to Herveus, the grandfather of Theobald Walter, it is not unlikely.
38 It must be a very large estate which Theobald possessed inxxi Norfolk and Suffolk ; for though he was not sheriff of those coun- ties in the first of king John, yet in the pipe roll of that year he is mentioned among other tenants in capite in the following entry, Theobaldus Walterus reddit compotum de IxxW. et xiiis. et \\\\d. In the second of that king in the pipe roll for Lancashire, Roger de Hetton accounts for 15 marks "pro habenda seisina de quadam ter- ra de Brome, qualem habuit die quo Theobaldus Walteri eum dis- seisivit et cartam suam abstulit." In the accounts of the sheriff
of the same county for the next year are these two entries, viz. " Homines de Preston reddunt compotum de x marcis et i palefrido pro habenda pace de loquela quam Teobaldus Walteri versus eos de gibeto et gaiol in Preston ; et Teobaldus Walteri r. c. de ii marcis pro feodo dim. militis." In the 4th of John we find in the pipe roll of Lancashire this entry, Teobaldus Walteri r. c. de vi marcis pro feodo trium militum, the service by which he held all Amoundernesse ; and another in the fifth year of that prince to this effect, Teobaldus Walteri debet ii palefrid pro ha- benda licentia eundi in Yberniam.
39 Theobald was now far advanced in years, and made haste after his return to Ireland to finish the abbey of Witheney, alias Wotheney or Woney, in the county of Limerick, which he had begun some years before, and which he now endowed ; on which account the annals of Ireland fix the foundation of that monastery in the year 1205. He died in the year following, the yth of king John, and was buried in this abbey. It was not the only religious house of his foundation ; for about the year 1 200 he founded and endowed the priory or hospital of S. John Bap- tist near Nenagh, in the county of Tipperary, for the main- tenance of Augustine canons and the sick that served God there. (See Monast. Ang. vol. ii. p. 1044.) Mention has been
THE INTRODUCTION. xlix
already made of his founding and endowing the abbey of Cocker- sand in Lancashire, and of the benefaction which he gave to that of Furnesse in the same county : but besides these, he founded likewise a convent at Arkelo, in the county of Wicklow, to serve as a cell to the last of those abbeys. (Ib. p. 1025.)
40 Upon his death, the lands which he held in England were seized into the king's hands, and accounted for in the exchequer. Thus we find in the pipe roll 9 Johannis for Lancashire, under the title of Compotus termrum Theobaldi Walteri, this entry, viz. " Idem Vicecomes, ut custos, reddit compotum de xxix/. et ixs. et iiii^. de firma Wapentac de Agmondernes de hoc anno, et de mil. de perquisitionibus, et de xixL et xiid. de firma dominiorum prsedicti Theobaldi, et de v marcis de exitibus prsedict1 terrarum. Summa Ivl. et xviis." Theobald married Maude daughter of Robert le Vavasour, a great Yorkshire baron, with whom he had Edelington and other lands in that county by way of portion, as appears from a plea roll 3 Edw. I. (de Banco Regis Term. Mich. Rot. 29. Ebor. et Rot. 13. Leicestr') wherein Theobald de Botiller claims a plough-land in Edelington, as his right of in- heritance from the said Maude with whom it had been given in marriage, against Agnes Becan, who seems to have been in pos- session of the land, and derived her title from Fulk Fitz -Warren, but called likewise upon John Vavasour to warrant her claim. John acknowledged the seisin of Maude, and the right of Theo- bald, as set forth in his plea ; but as Maude had after her first husband's death given back the land to her father Robert Vava- sour, he desired the judgment of the court, whether it did not rightfully belong to himself, as descended from the said Robert, and heir to his estate. There seems to have been a good deal of confusion in the title, occasioned by those exercises of the pre- rogative royal by king John, in the disposal of lands, which gave occasion to Magna Charta.
41 Maude seems to have been left a young widow upon Theobald xxii Walter's death, and her father obtained a grant of her mar- riage and jointure. This appears from two close rolls in the Tower of London, the one of the 7th, the other of the 9th of king John, m. 5. The first is thus expressed : " Rex vicecomiti Lin- colne, &c. Sciatis quod commisimus in balliam' Roberto le Vavasour Matildam filiam suam quse fuit uxor Theobaldi Walter cum dote et maritagio suo, et omnibus in eis inventis, &c." The other is, " Rex milero filio Henrici justiciario Hiberniae salutem.
ORMOND, VOL. i. e
1 THE INTRODUCTION.
Mandamus vobis, quod sine dilatione faciatis Roberto le Vava- sour vel certo nuncio suo rational1 dotem Matildis filise suse, quse fuit uxor Theobaldi Walter, &c." Robert was to pay the king no less than 1 200 marks, a very great sum in those days, for this grant ; which however he did not long enjoy, at least with- out disturbance; for his majesty thought fit, notwithstanding the said grant, to dispose of her in marriage to Fulk Fitz- Warine. This appears from the sheriffs of Yorkshire and Lan- cashire their accounts in the pipe roll 9 Johannis, where may be read the following passage : " Robertus le Vavasour debet m et cc marcas et ii pal ef rid, pro maritanda filia sua quse fuit uxor Teobaldi Walteri, et pro habendo maritagio suo et dote sua de libero tenemento, quod fuit Teobaldi Walteri quondam viri sui tarn in Ybernia quam in Anglia, excepto Agmundernesse ; et tertium suum intra Agmundernesse et Aleton, et de terris quce fuerunt patris ipsius Teobaldi, qua eidem Teobaldo Jiere- ditarie descenderant , habebit, si de hoc fine Fulco filius Warini in Salope sciat." Upon the marriage of Maude with the said Fulk arose a dispute between this her second husband and her father about the lands of Edelington, as is evident from the following records. In Rot. Pip. 10 Johannis Ebor. is this entry, " Robertus le Vavasour debet i palefrid pro recognitione nove disseisine versus Fulconem filium Warini de tenemento suo in Edlinton coram Rege ;"" and in the roll of the following year, " Fulco filius Warini debet xx marcas quod Robertus le Vava- sour summoneatur coram Rege ostensurus quo warranto tenet se in terra de Edlinton.1' Fulk seems to have got the better in the dispute, either by his interest or money; for in 12 Johannis Ebor. we read, " Fulco fiT Warini reddit compotum de cl. pro habenda seisina manerii de Edlinton •" and in 13 Johannis, " Fulco fil. Warini r. c. de xlvn7. et vs. pro habenda seisina manerii de Edlinton, et viii marc, pro Johanne Malherbi." This manor and other lands in Yorkshire came back afterwards to the descendants of Theobald Walter.
42 Theobald II, son and heir of Theobald the first butler of Ire- land, was but about five or six years old at his father's death. When he came of age, he was upon proof thereof, in the sixth year of king Henry III, put into the possession of his estate in Ireland ; as appeareth from the following writs among the close rolls in the Tower. " Glaus. 5 H. III. m. 6. Theobaldus Walter (plene etatis) filius Theobaldi Walter habet seisinam de terris suis in
THE INTRODUCTION. li
Hibernia. Test' &c. 2 Julii et Glaus. 6 H. III. m. 2. Rex, &c. H. Dublin! archiepiscopo justiciario suo Hibernie salutem. Man- damus vobis quod de omnibus terris et tenementis de quibus Theobaldus Walter pater dilecti et fidelis nostri Theobaldi Wal- ter Pincerne seisitus fuit die quo obiit; que quidem terre et tenementa ipsum Theobaldum Pincernam jure contingunt here- ditario, et que fuerunt in custodia domini regis patris nostri ratione rninoris etatis ipsius Theobaldi, plenam ei seisinam sine dilatione habere faciatis. Teste, &c. apud Turrim London. 18 Julii 6 Hen. III." This writ put Theobald II in possession of the greatest part of his Irish estate ; but a third of it continued almost all his life in the hands of Fulk Fitz-Warine, who en- joyed it in virtue of the king's writ, which is found in the close rolls 9 Johannis, m. 14, thus expressed : " Rex, &c. Willielmo dexxiii Braosa salutem. Mandamus vobis quod sine dilatione faciatis habere Fulconi filio Warini et Matildi que fuit uxor Theobaldi Walter, vel certo nuncio suo rationabilem dotem ipsius Matildis que earn contingit, scilicet tertiam partem de terris et tenementis que idem Theobaldus Walterus de nobis tenuit in Hibernia, quia reddidimus prefato Fulconi et Matildi de maritag' et dotem ipsius Matildis integre, sicut earn concessimus prius Roberto le Vavassour patri ipsius Matildis, (fee." Theobald II was likewise put into the possession of part of his English estate ; for in Rot. Pat. 8H.III. m. 13, we read, " Theobaldus Walter habet ma- nerium de Merton in com. Lane." and in the pipe roll 9 H. III. Lane. I find this entry, " Theobaldus Walter r. c. de dimid. feod. de Wedington ibid, et dimid. feod. in Boxted Norfolc." The power of Fulk Fitz-Warine seems to have kept his other lands from him, though he is charged in the accounts of the sheriff for Norf. and Suff. 4 H. Ill with 25 £. for lands in those counties.
43 Theobald II married Joane, sister of John de Marreis, or de Marisco, of an ancient Norman family, and a considerable baron in Ireland, to whose estate in that kingdom, as well as in Eng- land, his posterity afterwards became heirs. This marriage appeareth from a record in the Tower of London, among the escheat rolls of 22 R. II, to this effect: " Inquisitio capta in com. Somerset' 18° die Martii anno 22 Richardi secundi post mortem Joannis Trivet chevalier, &c. Juratores dicunt quod quidam Thomas Salumpton clericus et alii seisit' de manerio de Hunspill Marreis dederunt manerium prsedictum Stephano de
lii THE INTRODUCTION.
Marreis militi et Leticise uxori ejus, habend' eis ad vitam, re- manere Johanni Trivet chevalier et heredibus masculis de cor- pore suo, remanere rectis heredibus ipsius Stephani ; et Johannes Trivet obiit sine hered' mascuP de corpore suo, et quod Jacobus le Botiller nunc comes de Ormonde est consanguineus Stephani, et rectus heres ejus propinquior, viz. filius Jacobi, fiP Jacobi, fiP Edmundi, fiT Theobald, fiP Johannse sororis Johannis Marreis patris Hereberti, patris prsedicti Stephani de integro sanguine; et quod dictus Jacobus nunc comes de Ormonde est setatis 39 annorum et amplius, &c." This marriage seems to have been contracted whilst he was a minor; for in 18 H. Ill an account was taken in the exchequer of Ireland of the profits of his lands and marriage, as appears by a record in Bermingham's Tower, viz. " Johannes filius Galfridi reddit compotum de 3000 marcis pro custodia terrarum quse fuerunt Theobaldi Pincernse, una cum maritagio heredis ejusdem Theobaldi.1' This Theobald II was lord justice of Ireland in 1 247 , and died in the year follow- ing, being the 32d of Henry III. He gave (as appears from the deed of donation) a considerable part of his lands in Sleiwn, with the tithes that lay near the church, to the priory of All Saints at Dublin. He left issue Theobald his son and heir, very young ; as appears from the inquisition taken after his death in 33 H. Ill, (A.D. 1249,) wherein it was found " that this Theobald de Botiller died possessed of the manor of Bellag in Staffordshire, and divers other lands in that county, of the manor of Wichton in Lancashire, of Tiberley in the county of York; and that Theobald his son and heir was six years of age." It i? not unlikely but Theobald II might have a younger son, though no notice be taken of him in the pedigree ; for in the close roll of 37. m. 3, entitled, Pro Petro de Sabaudia, there is a writ of the king's dated July 22, at Winton, and directed to John Fitz- Geoffrey, justice of Ireland, requiring him to pay to the said Peter 200 marks, which he was bound to pay the king at Easter last, for the custody of the land and heirs of Theobald le Botiller, and the marriage of the said heirs.
44 Theobald III married Margery daughter of Richard de Burgo, xxiv son of William Fitz-Adelm, who died governor of Ireland in 1177, and was ancestor to the Clanricard family. Richard granted to him with his daughter in frank marriage, the manors of Ardmaile, Kilmorrackill, and divers other lands, as appears by the deed preserved among the evidences at Kilkenny. He
THE INTRODUCTION. liii
adhered to the king in the barons' wars ; and in 1 264, when Maurice Fitz-Maurice the second earl of Desmond surprised Richard de Capella the lord justice at Castle Dermot, this Theo- bald le Botiller, lord of Carrick, was taken with him; but a parliament meeting soon after at Kilkenny ordered them to be released ; which was done accordingly. He died and was buried in the convent of the friars preachers at Arcklow, leaving Theo- bald IV his son and heir. Mr. Butler, the clergyman before mentioned, pretends that he had a younger son named Richard, who settled in Lancashire, and from whom are descended the Butlers of Wales, (the eldest family of this branch,) who give azure 3 cups or ,• the Butlers of Aston le Walls in Northampton- shire, who give the same coat, with the addition of a chevron ; and lastly the Butlers of Rawcliffe and Kirkland in Lancashire, distinguished from both by a chevron and an half-moon. But as he produceth no authorities to prove this account of the descent of those families, no stress can be laid upon his assertions ; which differ in this point from all the pedigrees of the family. 45 Theobald IV, butler of Ireland, married Joane the youngest daughter of John Fitz- Geoffrey, earl of Essex, youngest son to the famous Geoffrey Fitz-Piers, lord justiciary of England before- mentioned. Her brothers John and Richard Fitz-John, earls of Essex, dying without issue, their lands were divided between her and her three sisters, whereof Maude, the eldest, was married to W. Beauchamp, earl of Warwick, Isabel, the second, to Robert de Vipount, and Aveline, the third, to Richard de Burgo, earl of Ulster. There were two partitions made of their brothers1 lands between these co-heiresses, one in the 26th, the other in the 27th of Edw. I. (See the close rolls 26 E. I. m. 18, 27 E. I. m. 13, and Rot. Fin. m. i, 2.) By the last partition Joane le Botiller had for her purpartie the manor of Faubrigg in Essex, the ham- let of Sheppeley in Hampshire, the manor of Shire in Surrey, with the hamlet called the Vacherie, and the manor of Aylesbury in Buckinghamshire ; which remained for some generations in the Ormond family. This partition was made some years after the death of Theobald, who died on Sept. 26, in the 13 th of E. I, A. D. 1 285, and left issue eight sons : i . Theobald, who succeeded him in his estate and butlership of Ireland ; 2. Edmund, after- wards earl of Carrick ; 3 . Thomas, from whom are descended the barons of Dunboyne in Ireland, so created in the 33d of Henry VIII, A. D. 1541; 4. John; 5. Richard; 6. Gilbert; 7. Nicholas;
liv THE INTRODUCTION.
and 8, James le Botiller. His eldest son was not yet of age, and thence became the king's ward, as appears from the escheat roll of 14 E. I, and the writ for the assignment of a dower to Joane his widow in several counties, dated the zd of February in that year. His lands were upon his death seized into the king's hands, and accounted for into the exchequer, as appears from the pipe roll of 16 E. I, Lane, where the sheriff accounts for " xxxiii£. iis. viiid. de redditu assiso in manerio de Wythington quod fuit Theobaldi de Botiller in com. Lane." as the sheriff of Yorkshire does for " cs. de redditu assiso in manerio de Schepeley quod fuit Theobaldi le Botiller qui obiit in Hibernia, a festo S. Matthsei apostoli anno xiii° fmiente, quo die rumor venit de morte ejusdem, usque ad xx diem Februarii anno xiiii0 antequam liber' easdem terras Johannse quse fuit uxor ejusdem pro xlviii^. de extenta earundem terrarum, prseter dotem per annum red- dendam per breve regis ; et de xis. vie?, de redd, ii bovat' terrre in Edlington quse fuerunt ejusdem Theobaldi per idem tempus." 46 Thus it is that the pedigrees of the family, sir Robert Rothe, xxv Mr. Roberts Ulvester king of arms, Mr. Butler, and others, with great unanimity state its descent, and I have paid so much deference to their accounts, as to recite them, and verify them wherever it could be done by records. But in the two last ar- ticles I cannot but differ from them, taking those Theobalds whom they distinguish as the third and fourth to be but one and the same person. My objections to their account are, that some of these writers say, that it was Theobald III who died and was buried at Arcklow, whilst others say it was The- obald IV, and yet none of them make above one of the fa- mily to be there buried ; none of them mention the time when Theobald III died ; nor do any of the old chronicles and his- tories of Ireland, which yet are very particular in mentioning the deaths of all the other heads of the family, take any no- tice of the death of a Theobald le Botiller between the 32 H. Ill, when it appears from undoubted records that Theo- bald II died, and the 13 E. I, when the same evidence proves that Theobald IV died. That interval contains only a space of 36 years, and as Theobald III was but six years old at his father's death, it is reasonable to expect that he left his son a minor at his own ; especially when that son, dying at the end of the interval, left eight sons alive behind him, besides daugh- ters : and yet there is no record known that takes notice of any
THE INTRODUCTION. Iv
such minority, on which occasion so many of different sorts, for seizing of the lands, grant of wardship, accounts of profits, livery of lands, &c., and of dowry, if the wife survived, were necessary. Hence I suppose that the son of Theobald II lived till 1285, and then left those eight sons, from the 5th of which possibly (as Mr. Butler imagines) the Butlers of Rawdecliffe. &c. may be descended. All the difficulty lies in the two marriages, which indeed are undeniably proved, and which I suppose gave occasion to the mistake : but I see all the reason in the world to think that Theobald III, being left at six years of age a ward to the king, was married before he came out of his minority ; nor is there any difficulty in supposing that he married to his first wife Margery, daughter of Richard de Burgo, and she dying without issue he afterwards married Joane, daughter of John Fitz-Geoffrey earl of Essex, who survived him many years. What would absolutely determine me in this opinion, (if there were no mistake in Mr. Roberts'® transcript,) is the plea-roll of 24 E. I. m. 68, preserved in Berminghana's tower. This roll contains the plea of Theobald the last of the name Butler of Ire- land, setting forth his right to the lands of Corky tyn, &c. pos- sessed by Hugh Purcel, and granted by Theobald the first Butler of Ireland with his daughter Beatrix in marriage to Thomas de Hereford, upon condition of reverting to himself and his heirs in defect of issue by that marriage. This obliged the last Theo- bald to set forth his descent, which he does in these words : " Unde dicit quod post mortem prsedictorum Thomse et Beatricis jus prsedictorum tenementorum per formam donationis prsedictf revertit et revertere debuit prsedicto Theobaldo Walter anteces- sori suo, eo quod prsedict" Thomas et Beatrix obierunt sine hered' de corporibus suis exeuntibus, ut preedictum est, et de prsedicto Theobaldo Walter descendit jus et descendere debuit cuidam Theobaldo le Botiller ut filio et heredi ; et de ipso Theobaldo le Botillera ut filio et heredT, et de ipso Theobaldo descendit jus et descendere debuit cuidam Theobaldo le Botiller ut filio et heredi qui nunc petit et inde producit bonam sectam." 47 That there is a mistake in this record, or the copy of it, seems probable from the transcript made by sir James Ware of another
a Here possibly the words cuidam Theobaldo le Botiller may be left out ; an omis- sion common enough, when the same name strikes the eye of the transcriber so often, that without the greatest attention he can hardly miss catching at it in the wrong place.
Ivi THE INTRODUCTION.
out of the register of Ossory, and to be found among his manu- xxvi scripts, in which it is expressly and distinctly asserted, that there were five Theobalds butlers of Ireland in immediate suc- cession to one another. The words of it are these : " Notum sit omnibus, quod cum placitum motum fuit in curia domini Edwardi fiP Edwardi regis Anglise coram justiciar' ejusdem regis de banco apud Dublin super advocatione medietatis ecclesise beatse Ma- rise de Baligawran per breve de Quare impedit, inter nobilem virum dominum Edmundum le Botiller querentern, et decanum et capitulum ecclesise sancti Canici Kilkenny impedientes. quam medietatem idem decanus et capitulum in proprios detinet usus, pro jure dicti Edmundi et hered1 suorum, et actionem quam idem Edmundus habet in posterum extinguendo et totaliter in perpe- tuum annullando. Nos Johannes dictus Lupus ecclesise S. Canici ut prsemittitur decanus et ejusdem loci capitulum, de consilio et assensu venerabilis patrisWillielmiDei gratia Ossoriensis episcopi, concedimus, et nos et successores nostros tenore prsesentium obli- gamus, teneri dicto Edmundo et hered'suis ad inveniend'et susten- tand' quatuor idoneos sacerdotes sumptibus suis admissos in dicta ecclesia B. Marise de Balygawran vel alibi in dicta villa, ubi idem Edmundus et hered' sui eligere voluerint pro prsedicto Edmundo et Johanna uxore ejus et filiis et filiabus ejus, et pro omnibus an- tecessoribus et successoribus eorundem viventium et defunctorum, et pro animabus Theobaldi Walteri primi Pincernse Hiberniae, Theobaldi secundi, Theobaldi tertii, Theobaldi quarti patris Theo- baldi quinti et dicti Edmundi, Theobaldi quinti, Johannis, Richardi, Gilberti, Nicholai et Jacobi fratrum prsedicti Edmundi, Matil- dis et Johannse sororum prsedicti Edmundi ; et pro animabus om- nium aliorum antecessorum et successorum suorum perpetuo celebrando. Et si contingat nos vel successores nostros circa inventionem et sustentationem dictorum quatuor sacerdotum vel alicujus eorum in toto vel in parte ut prsemissum est deficere vel cessare, volumus et concedimus, et pro nobis et successoribus, quod tenemur dicto Edmundo et hered" suis in quadraginta libris argenti, nomine puri debiti ; et hoc toties quoties nos vel succes- sores nostri defecerimus vel cessaverimus in dicta sacerdotum inventione et sustentatione, &c. In quorum omnium testimo- nium sigillum nostrum commune sub testimonio venerabilis patris dicti Willielmi antedicti prsesentibus duximus apponi. Dat" apud Kilkenn' 2° die Novembris anno 1312, et sexto Edw. secundi." Sir Robert Rothe, in his treatise of the family, p,i43, says, he
THE INTRODUCTION. Ivii
hath seen among Thomas earl of OrmoncTs evidence, an exem- plification of this record under the great seal of Ireland. 48 It is so authentic and clear an evidence of there being five Theobalds butlers of Ireland, that nothing can be advanced against it of sufficient weight to render its testimony doubtful. And yet it is so very improbable that Theobald IV should have ten children before 1285, when his father was born only in j 243, that I cannot but think that these two last named were but one person ; that Theobald II, left a minor, was married and died young, and that it was Theobald III, who died in 1 248 ; there being 48 years at least for two degrees, for one child in each, in this case ; whereas in the other two degrees there are but 42 years, and yet ten children in one to be accounted for. What renders this still more impossible to be conceived, is, that the eldest of these children was seventeen years old when his father Theobald IV died. This appears from the pipe roll of 1 8 E. I, where the sheriff of Lancashire among the Nova oblata^ accounts for an hundred marks paid by " Theobaldus fil. Theo- baldi le Botiller pro seisina terrarum suarum hie et in Hibernia, sicut cont' in orig. anni xviii." This record shews that Theo- bald V must be at least 1 7 years of age when his father died, (which was at the conclusion of 13 E.I.) and perhaps he might be more, since the sheriffs do not always account for the reliefs and liveries of lands within the year that they are given, andxxvii the money becomes due. However this be, I have hinted all I can think of to solve the difficulty.
49 Theobald V, butler of Ireland, was present in a parliament of the great lords of Ireland called by John Wogan lord justice in 1295, and stands the fifth in the roll. The king soon after summoning the great men of that kingdom to attend him in his invasion of Scotland, this Theobald, with the lord justice, Richard de Burgo earl of Ulster, and others, went over thither early in the spring, and (as Holinshed says) were nobly entertained by him on Whitsunday May 13, 1296, at a solemn feast in the castle of Roxburgh. Theobald accompanied Edward I in all this ex- pedition, (wherein Edinburgh and all the fortresses of Scotland were reduced,) and gained a great reputation by his valour upon all occasions. He died unmarried, and without issue, at Turvey, on May 14, 1299. and was buried on the 27th of that month in the abbey of Wotheney.
50 Edmond le Botiller his second brother succeeded Theobald V
Iviii THE INTRODUCTION.
in his estate and in the butlership of Ireland. In 1302 (30 E. I) a parliament was called in Ireland, at which he assisted, being mentioned in the roll by the name of Edmund le Botiller: and in the same year he recovered the manor of Holywood in Fingall from the archbishop of Dublin, by fine or concord be- tween them in the king's bench. In the 3ist of Edw. I he was summoned to attend the king into Scotland, and came with his men to Dublin in order to embark for that kingdom ; but it was not thought advisable that he should leave Ireland at that time by reason of some disturbances within the realm. The king first resented his not coming, and put a stop to the granting him livery of the lands of his mother Joane, daughter of John Fitz Geoffrey earl of Essex, who died about this time ; but un- derstanding the truth of the matter, ordered livery to be granted him by the following writ : " Rex dilecto et fideli suo Waltero de Glocester escheatori suo ultra Trentam salutem. Accepimus per inquisitionem quam per vos fieri fecimus, quod Edmundus le Botil- ler de Hibernia est filius et heres Johanne le Botiller defuncte, que de nobis tenuit in capite die quo obiit, et plene etatis : et quia idem Edmundus tempore quo dilectus et fidelis noster Richardus de Burgo comes Ultonie fuit apud Dublin in veniendo ad nos versus Scotiam, accessit ibidem hominibus ad arma sufficienter munitus et paratus ad veniend1 ad nos in obsequium nostrum cum eodem comite ad partes Scotie supradict1 ; ac pro eo quod pro nostra et dicte terre nostre Hibernie securitate et conimodo, de communi consilio et assensu fidelium nostrorum partium ilia- rum tune apud Dublin existentium fuit unanimiter concordatum, quod idem Edmundus cum posse suo in auxilium aliorum fide- lium nostrorum partium earundem moram faceret in partibus Hibernie supradict', &c. Et ideo vobis mandamus quod accepta securitate de prsefato Edmundo de rationabili relevio suo et plenarn ei seisinam de terris praed"1 Johanne matris sue habere faciatis, &c. Teste rege apud Dumferline 13 Jan. anno regni nostri 32."
51 In the year following, Edmund was governor of the kingdom by the style of Gustos Hibernie, as appears by thirty rolls of the 33 E. I, preserved in Bermingham's tower. Mr. Roberts says, that about seven years after, upon the repair of John Wogan, justice of the kingdom, into England, Edmund le Botiller was by letters patents appointed to govern it as lieutenant to the said Wogan, but refused it (as it seems) because he had been for-
THE INTRODUCTION. lix
merly (viz. in the year beforementioned) chief governor of Ire- land. This appears by a patent roll 6 E. II, among the rolls of the exchequer of Ireland, where in the margin of the roll, at the foot thereof, and at the end of the first commission, is written vacat, quia idem Edmundus illam commissionem noluit accipere, &c. And then, immediately after the said commission, follows another there enrolled, whereby he is made custos terrce Hiber- xxviii nice. Mr. Roberts adds, that as he finds by the test of many records that this Edmund was several times custos Hibernice, so could find no Irish record wherein he is styled Justiciarius Hiber- nice, to which custos and deputatus are equivalent, except in a common plea roll 10 E. II. in. 26, in Bermingham's tower. He met also with an English one, in which the king styles him Jus- ticiarius Hibernice ; the close roll 8 E. II. m. 14, in dorso in the Tower of London, running in these words, " Rex, &c. dilectis et fidelibus nostris Edmundo le Botiller Justiciario, Ricardo de Be- reford cancellario, et magistro Willielnio de I slip thesaurario nostro Hibernige," &c.
52 About the end of the 1 2th century, the ancient see of Roscree had been united to that of Killaloe, and king John, with the consent of Cornelius CTHenry bishop of Killaloe, had erected a castle at Roscree, the custody of which was committed to The- obald Walter II, (see Rot. Pat. 8 H. III. m.Q,) but the manor still remained to the bishop's successors, till Matthew CTHogan ex- changed it with king Edw. I for some lands near Newcastle in the county of Dublin. This manor of Roscree was by that king granted to Edmund le Botiller, who was afterwards created earl of Carrick by Edward II, in the ninth year of his reign, on Sept. i, 1315, by the following patent, which I have transcribed from the original under the great seal preserved in the castle of Kilkenny : " Rex archiepiscopis, episcopis, abbatibus, prioribus, *tot. Pa comitibus, baronibus, justiciariis, vicecomitibus prsepositis, mini- pro Ed_
stris et omnibus ballivis et fidelibus suis salutem. Sciatis nos ^u^0 le
Botiller
pro bono et laudabili servitio quod dilectus et fidelis noster Ed- de Hiber. mundus le Botiller de Hibernia nobis hactenus impendit et im- pendet in futurum dedisse concessisse et hac carta nostra confir- masse eidem Edmundo manerium de Karryke Makgriffijn cum pertinent' et castrum et manerium de Roskre cum pertinent' in Hibernia, habend' et tenend' eidem Edmundo et heredibus suis cum feodis militum, advocationibus ecclesiarum, et omnibus aliis
Ix THE INTRODUCTION.
ad prsedicta castrum et maneria pertinentibus, videlicet, prcedic- tum manerium de Karryk cum pertinentiis sub nomine et honore comitis de KarriJce de nobis et hered' nostris per servitium duo- rum feodorum militum in perpetuum. Quare volumus et firmiter prsecipimus pro nobis et hered1 nostris quod prsedictus Edmundus habeat et teneat prsedicta castrum et maneria cum pertinen' sibi et heredibus suis cum feodis militum, advocationibus ecclesi- arum, et omnibus aliis ad prsedicta castrum et maneria perti- nentibus, videlicet, prsedictum manerium de Karryke cum pertinen1 sub nomine et honore comitis de KarryJce, de nobis et hered1 nostris per servitium duorum feodorum militum in perpetuum, sicut prsedict1 est. Hiis testibus venerabilibus patribus W. archiepi- scopo Cantuar1 totius Anglise primate, et J. Norwicen' episcopo, Thoma comite Lancastr', Johanne de Britannia comite Rich- mund, Humfrido de Bohun comite Hereford et Essex, Roberto filio Walteri, Johanne de Crumwell senescallo hospitii nostri et aliis. Dat per manum nostram apud Lincolne primo die Sep- tembris per ipsum regem. Et mandatum est Ricardo de Bere- ford cancellar1 regis Hibern1 quod eidem Edmundo seisina de Castr' et maneriis prsedict' per literas sub sigillo regis Hibernise fact' tenend' juxta tenorem cartse prsedict', ut supra." 53 This patent was afterwards recited verbatim in a Latin in- strument under the great seal of Ireland, (as a patent of king Edw. I,) and confirmed by Edw. Ill upon an inspeximus. After the recital follow these words : " Nos autem cartam prsedict1 ad requisitionem dilecti consanguinei et fidelis nostri Jacobi le Bo- tiller comitis Ormond' tenore prsesentium duximus exemplificand'. In cujus rei testimonium has literas nostras fecimus patentes, teste Leonello comite Ulton' filio nostro carissimo locum tenente nostrum in terra nostra Hibern' vi. die April, anno regni nostri trigesimo octavo.11 The kings Edw. I and II used the same style xxix in their patents; so that it is only the date and the names of the witnesses, which can in many cases distinguish them ; and though the names of Walter archbishop of Canterbury and of John bishop of Norwich sufficiently shew this to be a patent of the latter, yet the mistake of assigning it to the former might easily be made in Ireland, where it was well known that Carry ke had belonged to the family of le Botiller long before the time of Edw. II, and Roskre had been given to it by Edw. I (as sir James Ware says) in 1281; unless this learned antiquary^ mis-
THE INTRODUCTION. Ixi
take in that point was occasioned by this exemplification, as may be imagined, because that year of our Lord is the ninth of the reign of that prince.
54 This grant was probably made to Edmund le Botiller, in con- sideration of some good service which he had done the crown in the year before, when he was chief governor of Ireland. It was attended with another, contained in the following record, which is attested by the same witnesses: " Rex archiepiscopis, &c. sa- lutem. Sciatis nos pro bono et laudabili servitio quod dilectus et fidelis noster Edmundus le Botiller de Hibern' nobis hactenus impendit et impendet in futurum concessisse eidem Edmundo, quod ipse et heredes sui in perpetuum habeant retorn' omnium brevium nostrorum et hered' nostrorum in cantredis suis de Oreman, Elyeogerth, et Elye Karroyle in com. Typerary, et ea quse ad hujusmodi retorn1 pertinent, quare volumus et firmiter prsecipimus pro nobis et hered' nostris quod prsed' Edmundus et heredes sui in perpetuum habeant retorn1 omnium brevium nos- trorum et hered' nostrorum in cantredis prsed' et ea quae ad hujusmodi retorn' pertinent, sicut prsedictum est. Hiis testibus, &c. daf ut supra per ipsum regem. Et mandat est prsefato cancellario quod inspect1 tenore cartse prsedictae literas sub sigillo regis Hibern' eidem Edmundo super prsemissas in forma debita fieri faciat, &c. Test' ut supra."
55 The patent for the earldom of Carrick runs in the usual style of patents of that age, when the title of earl was not taken from a county, (in which case either the third penny of the profits of the county, or an annuity of id. a year in lieu thereof, was usually settled for the support of the honour,) but from a par- ticular place or town. The patent for creating Andrew de Harla earl of Carlisle in 15 E. II, runs in the same form; and so do several others where the title of earl is taken from a county ; as those of 34 E. I, constituting John de Bretagne earl of Richmond,, of i E. II, for Piers G-aveston to be earl of Cornwall, and 6 E. II, for Thomas de Brotherton to be earl of Norfolk, and others, which might be mentioned were it needful. Edmund had by the patent before recited an estate in fee not only in the manor, but in the honour of earl of Carrick : and accordingly was so styled all his life, and his son after him, till he was created earl of Ormond, when the ancienter title of Carrick began to be disused. This in process of time occasioned a precedence to be given to the earls of Kildare, whose ancestor was raised to this title two
Ixii THE INTRODUCTION.
years after the erection of the earldom of Carrick, but before the title of Ormond was given to James le Botiller, whose descend- ants by that disuse came to lose a precedence which was unde- niably their due. I can see no reason for this disuse, but that creation money was not mentioned in the patent for Carrick, though the manor was a much better support for the honour, and that Ormond was a large territory, whereas the other was but a single manor ; which might make the family more fond of the title of Ormond. Whatever was the motive, it is certain that after the style of Ormonde was given to the family that of Carricke was so generally laid aside, that Mr. Roberts, after look- ing over many hundred records mentioning the late earls by the title of Ormonde, never could find but one record wherein that of Carricke was expressed. It is in a charter of escheated lands granted by king Edw. Ill to the second earl of Ormond, and to be found in the Tower of London among the patent rolls of 41 xxx E. Ill, p. 2. m. 10, in these words: " Rex, &c. Salutem. Sciatis quod de gratia nostra speciali et pro bono servitio quod dilectus consanguineus et fidelis noster Jacobus Comes d' Ormond et de Carrick nobis impendit in terra nostra Hibernise, &c. conces- simus pro nobis et hered' nostris eidem comiti oninia terr' et tenementa cum pertinentiis quse fuerunt Willielmi de Carran in Finagh et Fayrnoylin. Com. Waterford, &c. et quse per foris- factionem prsedicti Willielmi ad manus nostras tanquam escaeta devenerunt, fee." This grant was made to the said James for his good service, and to enable him the more decently to main- tain the state of an earl; and is dated at Westminster, 12 Nov. 41 E. Ill, as I see by the original under the great seal still pre- served in Kilkenny castle. It is remarkable that in this patent, where both titles are mentioned, that of Carricke, though the ancienter, is put last, which if it did arise from the carelessness of clerks in those days, shews a particular fondness for that of Ormonde. However this was, the honour of Carrick (as appears in the like cases) cannot be lost by any disuse of the title ; nor do I see but that this of Carrick was as much a local honour as that of Arundel, if we may judge by the terms in which both patents are drawn.
56 Edmond le Botiller lived in very unquiet times, when the Irish were continually breaking out into rebellion, and the Scots, under the command of Robert de Bruce's brothers infested the kingdom ; and had opportunities of doing considerable services
THE INTRODUCTION. Ixiii
to the crown. In 1307, the preying Irish of Offaly demolished the castle of Cashel, took the town of Ley and invested the castle, but were routed, and the siege raised by Edmond le Botiller and his father-in-law John Fitzgerald, commonly called Fitz Thomas. In the year following Edmund went over into England, and returned thence in 1309, having been knighted by Edw. II at London. In 13 1 2, being custos or guardian of the kingdom, he repressed the excursions of the Byrnes and Tools, and attacked them so warmly in their own fastnesses in Glen- delorie, that they were forced to submit, to avoid utter destruc- tion. He continued in the government all the next year, and on Michaelmas day dubbed thirty knights in the castle of Dublin. The Annals of Ireland, published by Camden, say, that he re- ceived a commission to be lord justice of that kingdom, on the Friday after St. Matthew, in 1314. In the spring following, Edward de Bruce, brother to Eobert king of Scotland, after hav- ing for some time, by the convenience of shipping, preyed upon the coasts of Ulster, landed in May with an army of 6000 men near Carrickfergus, routed the earl of Ulster near the Ban, and Roger Mortimer at Kenlis in Meath; took Grenecastle and Dundalk, besieged Carrickfergus, drove most of the English out of Ulster, and at last caused himself to be crowned king of Ireland. Edmonde le Botiller, the lord justice, assembled a mighty army out of Munster and Leinster to oppose him, and advanced in July to Dundalk, where he was joined by the earl of Ulster with a great force which he had raised in Connaght. The Scots re- tired, and must have been cut in pieces or taken prisoners if the old feuds between the burghs and Fitzgeralds had not broke out again upon their meeting ; which occasioned the army to sepa- rate, and the earl of Ulster pursuing the Scots as far as Cole- raine with his own forces, was there defeated : yet Edward Bruce thought fit to send the earl of Murray to Scotland for further supplies.
57 This invasion of the Scots encouraged the Irish of Connaght, Munster, Meath, and Leinster to rebel. They burnt the castles of Athlone and Raudon, and committed great ravages in all parts. Bruce, encouraged by their rebellion, and strengthened by their forces, marched into Meath and Kildare, burning and spoiling all before him; but was there opposed by the earl of Carrick, who had drawn together John Fitzgerald, Arnold Poer, and other noblemen of Leinster and Munster, with their fol-xxxi
Ixiv THE INTRODUCTION.
lowers. These made up a numerous army, but the same dissen- sions among the great lords, and disorders consequent thereof, happening as before, this body soon dispersed, without doing any kind of service ; the Scots afterwards retiring, for want of pro- visions, into Ulster. The lord justice improved that interval of quiet by calling a parliament, to reconcile the great men, and concert measures for carrying on the war. This necessary step being taken, Edmund thought it best to begin with the weaker enemy in Leinster, and having routed the O'Mores, who ravaged the country of Leix, attacked the Tools and Byrnes, who had risen again in arms and burnt Arckloe, Newcastle, Bree, and all the villages adjoining. These he defeated on the i6th of April, 1316: soon after which, Roger Mortimer came over, the king's lieutenant. The earl of Carrick still continued to do service with his own followers, and made a great slaughter of the Irish in two engagements which he had with them, one near Castle Dermot, and the other at Balylethen, and soon after slew 400 of those of Omayle. Bruce, reinforced out of Scotland, advanced in the be- ginning of the year 1317 with an army of 20,000 men towards Dublin, the citizens whereof were in a kind of rebellion, and had made the earl of Ulster prisoner : nor could the earls of Carrick and Kildare, with other noblemen, prevail for his release. From thence the Scots marched to Cashel and Nenagh, wasting the county of Tipperary. The earls of Carrick and Kildare, with other noblemen, drew down a strong army of 30,000 men to fight him, but were restrained by an order from Roger Mortimer ; who returning at this time with succours from England, landed at Youghall, and sent letters to the earl of Carrick, that he should attempt nothing against the Scots before his coming. Bruce did not think fit to wait that time, and retired with his forces into Meath, and thence into Ulster; where he did not subsist long, being in Oct. 1318 routed and killed, with 2000 of his men, by the lord John Bermingham, in a battle near Dundalk.
58 The Scots being driven out of Ireland, and the kingdom quieted after that defeat, Edmund earl of Carrick, in 1320, went over into England; and dying at London on Sept. 13, 1321, his corpse was carried over into Ireland, and on St. Martin's eve buried at Gowran. He had in 1302 married Joane, daughter of John Fitzgerald the first earl of Kildare ; and by her had issue, James his eldest son, who succeeded him in his honour and
THE INTRODUCTION. Ixv
estate; and another son, named John, who died in 1336, and from whom the viscounts of Skeryn are lineally descended. He had likewise a daughter named Joane, who was by her father affianced to Eoger, second son of Roger, and brother to Edward Mortimer earls of Marche, with iooo/. for her portion, as is specified in the covenants for that match in Rot. Glaus. 14 E. II, in dorso in. 9. He made an addition to his paternal estate by the purchase of the whole lordship of the barony of Juerke in Ossory, from Roger, son of Milo Poer baron thereof; the deed of conveyance being dated at Knoctopher, on the Wednesday after the feast of St. Gregory, in the twelfth year of Edward II.
59 James le Botiller, earl of Carricke, was under age at his father's death, and compounded for 2000 marks with king Edw. II for his marriage, the remainder of which sum was remitted to him upon his marriage with Eleanor, the eldest daughter then living of Humphrey de Bohun (the eighth of that name) earl of Here- ford and Essex, and constable of England, by Elizabeth the seventh daughter of king Edward I. He was of age, and had livery of his lands before the death of Edward II, as I see by a petition of his to Edw. Ill, and the king's writ to the justice and chancellor of Ireland thereupon, in relation to the prisage of wines all over Ireland ; in which, after having set forth his right,
and the dues thereon to be paid; the record runs in these xxxii words : " de qua quidem prisa antecessores sui prsedicti semper hactenus a tempore quo non extat memoria, in dominico suo ut de feodo obierunt seisiti ; et licet dominus Edwardus nuper rex Anglise pater noster cepisset homagium ipsius Jacobi de omnibus terris et tenementis quse prsefatus Edmundus pater suus tenuit de patre nostro in capite die quo obiit, eaque sibi per breve suum Justiciar' Hibernise directum mandasset liberari, idem tamen justiciar' prisam de vinis prsedict', et pro eo quod in brevi de prisa hujusmodi non sit expressa mentio, sed tantum de terris et tenementis eidem Jacobo liberari, hactenus detinet in ipsius Jacobi grave dampnum et exhered' pertinent' manifest' &c. Dat' primo die Martii anno primo, E. III."
60 James le Botiller having in the next year married the king's cousin-german with his majesty's consent, was on Oct. 13 there- upon created earl of Ormond, and on the 2d of November fol- lowing had a grant made him of id. a year annual rent of the farm of the city of Waterford, to be held by him and his heirs sub nomine et honore Oomitis de Ormonde. Soon after, viz. on
ORMOND, VOL. i. f
Ixvi THE INTRODUCTION.
Nov. 21, in the same year, the king, in consideration of his said marriage, pardoned him all that was behind of the fine of 2000 marks, which he was to pay for the liberty of marrying as he pleased. See Rot. Pat. 2 E. III. His majesty likewise (Rot. Pat. 5 July, 3 E. Ill) gave license to Edward de Bohun earl of Here- ford to grant the manors of Killpeck and Trunel, and the baily- ship of the forest of Hay in the county of Hereford, to the said James earl of Ormond and Eleanor his wife, and the heirs of their bodies. This alliance procured him still more considerable advantages, particularly the grant of the regalities and liberties of Tipperary, and the rights of a palatine in that county. The first grant thereof was for life only, and is dated Nov. 9, 1328. It is to be found among the Originalia 2 E. III. Rot. 20, and was enrolled in Ireland among the common pleas at Waterford, before Fr. Roger Outlawe, prior of Kilmainham, justice of Ire- land, on the Wednesday after the feast of S. Gregory, 3 E. III. The words of the patent are these : " Edwardus rex, &c. omni- bus ad quos, &c. salutem. Sciatis quod pro bono servitio quod — Jacobus le Botiller de Hibernia, quern in Comitem de Ormounde in Hibernia prsefecimus — Edwardo nuper regi Angliae patri nostro et nobis impend it — et ut ipse statimi et honor em comitis decen- tius valeat continere, dedimus et concessimus eidem comiti ad totam vitam suam regalitatem et alias libertates, cum feodis militum et omnibus aliis rebus qusecunque fuerunt quse habuimus in comitatu de Typerary in Hibernia (quatuor placitis, videlicet incendio raptu forestall"* et thesauro invento, ac etiam proficuo de croceis in dicto comitatu cum omnibus ad ea spectantibus, quse erga nos et heredes nostros volumus remanere, duntaxat ex- ceptis.) — In cujus rei testimonium has literas nostras fieri feci- mus patentes. Teste meipso apud Walyngford nono die No- vembris anno regni nostri secundo."
6 1 The four pleas mentioned in this patent are sufficiently under- stood ; but it may not be unuseful to explain what is meant by proficuo de croceis, because sir H. Spelman in his Glossary pro- fesseth not to understand it, and fancies it signifies a composition for murder. Whereas in truth, according to the affinity of the word, it expresseth something relating to the crosier or pastoral staff, and the profits thereof were either the advowsons of abbeys and churches, or the revenues of the lands of episcopal sees, abbeys, convents, and ecclesiastical benefices during their vacancy, as appears very plainly from two of the like grants to
THE INTRODUCTION. Ixvii
Walter de Lacy count palatine of Meath, in the first whereof an exception is made of the profic. de croceis, and in the latter this is explained by the excepting of advowsons of churches and the vacations of benefices. By this grant all treasons might be tried in the county of Tipperary, and in such cases the forfeitures xxxiii went to the lord, who could try all causes, except in the four reserved cases. This I find to be the opinion of counsel upon the grants of this palatinate, which they fortified by authorities in law drawn from Coke's 4 List. p. 205. 219, Dyer 288, sir J. Davy's Rep. f. 63, 64, and other authors. And in fact the earls of Ormond ever had such forfeitures, and tried such causes, till the time of the first duke of that name ; and all counts palatine have them, as particularly Hugh Lupus earl of Chester, and Thomas earl of Lancaster, mentioned in Coke's Inst. 4. p. 211. This palatinate had been given but'a few years to James earl of Ormond, before the king issued orders to seize into his own hands all the counties palatine in Ireland, it being represented to them that they were one cause of the dissensions and refrac- toriness of the great lords of that kingdom, and the source of infinite mischiefs to the people. But in consideration of this earl's consanguinity to himself, he thought fit to restore to him the palatinate of Tipperary by letters patent bearing date 23 April, ii E. III. When this earPs son, James II earl of Or- mond, came of age, the king made him a new grant thereof for his life by a patent dated 10 Jan. 29 E. Ill, and on June 5, in the 46th year of his reign, granted it in fee to that earl and his heirs ; in consequence whereof, it hath been constantly enjoyed by the family till our times. All these patents under seal are still preserved among the evidences at Kilkenny. 62 This James the first earl of Ormond, as soon as he was of age, engaged on the side of his uncle Thomas earl of Kildare in his quarrel with the Burghs and Poers. In 1329 the O'Nolans having treacherously taken sir H. Traherne in his own house at Kilbeg, he overran their country and burnt Foghird. In 1330 the Mac Geoghegans raised a disturbance in Meath, but were routed in two engagements by the earls of Ulster and Ormond ; and in the same year the latter of these noblemen was present in a parliament held at Kilkenny by Roger Prior of Kilmainham then lord deputy. In 1336, this earl founded the friery of Little Carig in the county of Waterford, for minorites, of which John Clyn, author of the Annals of Ireland, was the first guardian ;
f 2
Ixviii THE INTRODUCTION.
and dying on Jan. 6, 1337, 8, was buried at Gowran. He left issue only one son, James, who succeeded him, and one daughter, named Petronella, who was married to Gilbert lord Talbot, an- cestor of the Shrewsbury family.
63 James II earl of Ormond was but seven years old at his fa- ther's death. The king granted his wardship to the earl of Desmond, as appears by a record recited by sir R. Rothe in these words : " Mauritius Fitz-Thomas comes de Desmond dat domino regi 2300 marcas pro custodia terrarum in Hibernia quse fuerunt Jacobi le Botiller nuper comitis de Ormonde usque ad legitimam setatem heredis dicti comitis, una cum maritagio ejusdem heredis. Dat. i Sept. 18 E III." The manor of Ba- lygowran had been before given during the minority of the young earl to Hugh de Audeley earl of Gloucester and Margaret his wife. Rot. Pat. 13 E. III. This wardship seems to have been granted unusually late to the earl of Desmond, it being near seven years from the death of James I, earl of Ormond, which happened u E. Ill, and the grant which passed in the i8th of that king. It is possible the young earl might have been left to the care of his mother during that interval, and then taken from her upon her second marriage ; of which marriage I have seen a proof in a receipt dated at Kildare 8 Aug. 19 E. Ill, wherein Maurice Fitz-Thomas earl of Kildare acknowledgeth to have received from sir Thomas Dagworth, knight, and Eleanor, count- ess of Ermon, his wife, 20$. of silver by the hands of Simon de Flatesbury of the royal service proclaimed at Modessel before R. de Ufford, justice of Ireland, for the lands and service of the said Simon in Balymascollok in the barony of Cloncurry Offe-xxxiv Ian. Nor does the earl of Desmond seem to have long enjoyed the wardship granted him, being persecuted by sir Ralph Ufford, lord justice, his castles taken, his lands wasted, and himself forced to submit and surrender his person in A. D. 1345. He was upon this submission admitted to bail on the recognizance of the earls of Ulster and Ormond and twenty-four knights : but Ufford being a severe man, he thought it dangerous to appear according to the recognizance ; which was therefore estreated into the exchequer, and the penalties levied with great rigour upon all but the earl of Ormond, (whose minority, and being a ward to Desmond, was a just protection,) the earl of Ulster, and two others. Upon this occasion, of the earl of Des- mond's standing out against the royal authority, I suppose it
THE INTRODUCTION. Ixix
was, that on 24 March, 20 E. Ill, the king, by letters patent dated that day at Westminster, granted to sir John Darcy the father, (who was five times lord justice of Ireland, a man of great wisdom and valour, and ancestor to theDarcys of Flatten,) in consideration of his good services and of the sum of 1000?., the marriage of James le Botiller earl of Ormond, now in his minority. And on the 2d of April following granted him like- wise the custody of all the lands belonging to James late earl of Ormond, held of the king in capite during his son's minority. In consequence hereof, this James II earl of Ormond, (who, as his father, for an imperfection in his speech, had been by the Irish called James the stammerer, was on account of his modesty distinguished by the name of James the chaste,) was married to Elizabeth daughter of sir John Darcy, who, though she brought him no fortune, made him ample amends by her good qualities ; for she was a very wise and honourable lady.
64 This James was commonly called the noble earl, on account of his descent from the royal family, and being great-grandson to Edward I. It was this relation probably which procured him upon his coming of age a grant from king Edward III, of an annuity of 40^. for his life out of the lands and tenements that belonged to Walter son of Walter de Birmingham ; which his majesty afterwards revoking, gave him instead thereof the like annuity out of the fee- farm of the city of Waterford, by letters patent dated 30 Nov. 29 E. Ill, at Westminster. The king likewise on Nov. 5, in the 44th year of his reign, by his letters patent confirmed a conveyance of the manors of Inchecoyne and Youghall, and other lands in the counties of Waterford, Cork, and Limerick, made to this James II, in consideration of his good services; notwithstanding the conveyance was not good, by reason that Robert de Typcot the owner thereof, in virtue of whose feoffment the conveyance was made, had forfeited them by the act about absentees. The same king also, besides the lands of Finnagh in com. Waterford, forfeited by W. Carran, (as hath been before mentioned,) granted him on Feb. 6, in the 49th year of his reign, the manors of Dounbryn and Grenhagh in the county of Kilkenny, which had been forfeited to the crown by the attainder of Eustace son of Arnold le Poer for the treason on account of which he was hanged. Richard II, also by a pa- tent dated June 5, in the 3d year of his reign at Westminster, granted to the said James le Botiller earl of Ermon, and the
Ixx THE INTRODUCTION.
heirs male of his body for ever, the lands of Athbiller in the barony of Ouerk, in the county of Kilkenny, lately belonging to John Kermerdyn, who held the same from Edmund le Botiller earl of Carrick, and had forfeited them by adhering to the Scots and the king's enemies. The renewal of the grants of the prise wines and of the regalities of Tipperary to this earl and his heirs have been already mentioned.
65 This James II earl of Ormond was in 1339 made lord justice of Ireland, and going the next year into England, Maurice Fitz- Thomas earl of Kildare was constituted justice in his absence, but resigned the sword to the earl of Ormond upon his return xxxv within the year. In 1361, Sept. 8, Lionel son to king Edw. Ill, and earl of Ulster in right of his wife, landed at Dublin as the king's lieutenant, and brought with him a body of 1500 men in order to make an entire reduction of the Irish, and reformation of the degenerate English. Among other great men entertained by him, this earl of Ormond had 43. a day for himself, zs. a piece for two knights, is. a piece for twenty-seven esquires, 6d. a piece for twenty hoblers armed, and 4^. a piece for twenty hoblers unarmed. He did great service against the rebels in Ulster, Leinster, and Munster. He slew at Teagstoffin, in the county of Kilkenny, 600 of Mac Morrogh's men on the feast of St. Ke- nelm, 1362, as appears by certain ancient rolls and books re- maining with the corporation of Kilkenny. In 1364, the lord lieutenant went in April into England, leaving the earl of Or- mond lord deputy ; in which post he continued till the eighth of December following, when Lionel duke of Clarence returned to the government. In 1376, 50 E. Ill, this earl was, on July 24, again made lord justice, with an appointment of 500?. a year (the usual salary in those days) as long as he continued in that office. By a subsequent patent of Aug. 6, he had power to par- don all offences generally and to particular persons, and (by consent of the council) to remove any officer ; those made by patent under the great seal only excepted. By another writ of the same date the former commission was explained not to ex- tend to the pardon of any prelate or earl for any offence punish- able by loss of life, member, lands, or goods. He continued justice to the death of king Edward, and in the first year of Rich. II, keeping the kingdom in as good order as those danger- ous and troublesome times would admit of; for both the French and Scots took advantage of the king's infancy to disquiet his
THE INTRODUCTION. Ixxi
dominions. He held, according to the usage of those times, pleas of the crown and gaol delivery at the Naas on Monday after Valentine's day, in 1378, and soon after surrendered the sword to Alexander Balscot bishop of Ossory ; who holding a parliament, this earl is the first on the roll of the temporal lords, as he was also in that held in 4 R. II, A. D. 1380. He died on Saturday Oct. 18, 1382, 6 R. II, in his castle of Knoctopher, near which he had in 1356 founded an house of Carmelite friars; and was buried in S. Kenny's church at Kilkenny. He left issue only one son, James, who succeeded him in his honours.
66 James III, earl of Ormond, was not of age when his father died, as appears from a record in Birmingham's tower, among the escheators' accounts in the 19 Rich. IT. This record shew- eth, " that by an information preferred in the king's behalf, one William Fitz -William, escheator of Ireland, was charged upon his accounts with the issues, rents, and profits of the manors of Corduffe Ruish, Tullogh O'Phelim, Hand Nenagh, Thurles, Ard- mayle, Carrickmagriffin, moiety of the manors of Bree Drom- denyn, Bahoth in Arckloe, Kilmardinston, and the liberties and regalities of Tipperary, the moiety of the baronies of Inchiquin, Youghall, and Kinsale, the advowsons of the church of Youghall, and with one messuage and five acres of land in the island In- chemanell and the manor of Finagh, the barony of Cahirkinles and advowson thereof, and the prise wines of all the ports and places near the sea, as well cities and towns, as other places in the realm of Ireland (except all the prisage of Cork, and half the prisage of Waterford) ; all which came to the king's hands by reason of the death of James le Botiller, late earl of Ormond, for that his son and heir was within age at the time of his father's decease, &c." The rest of the estate and the excepted part of the prisage were (I suppose) assigned to his mother for her thirds, or jointure ; for after he came of age, sir Robert Rothe says, she resigned to him all her dower, except her share of the xxxvi prise wines ; and of this surrender of hers, in which the grant
of the prise wines from the crown is recited, there was an exem- plification among the evidences at Kilkenny.
67 This earl built the castle of Gowran, and making it his usual residence was from thence commonly called earl of Gowran ; and so other earls of Ormond were often written earls of Tippe- rary, either because Ormond and Carrick lay in that county, or because they had the regality of that county palatine. So the
Ixxii THE INTRODUCTION.
earls of Arundel were often called earls of Sussex, and Gilbert de Clare, (who in king Stephen's time was, as Richard his father had been before him, earl of Hertford,) was, as well as his suc- cessors, generally styled earls of Clare, which was their principal seat and habitation, and often wrote themselves by that title. It was this earl who first purchased the castle of Kilkenny, which afterwards became the chief seat of the family. The deeds by which sir Hugh le Despenser conveyed it to him his heirs and assigns for ever are dated Sept. 4 and 12, 15 R. II, and are still preserved in that castle. The purchase was very considerable, as comprehending the castle of Kilkenny with the mills, the borough of Rosbargon with the mills, the manors of Dunfret and Kildermoy, the sergeancy of Ouerk, all his tenements in Kalian le Hill, 33^. 155. $d. rent in Kalian, and advowson of the church, with all the lands, tenements, advowsons, and knight's fees in Nouerk, Rosbargon, Logheran, Killagh, Rossinan, Illid, Knoctofre, the new town of Jeripont, Kyllamery, Ardereston, Lysdonfy, Kilfe- chrai, Newtowne de Erley, Rathgulekeby, Kiltramayn, Rathama- duff, and Thollehanbroge. These lands had in the reign of Edw. Ill been by a deed enrolled in the chancery of Ireland granted by John son of Peter de Hothum, knight, son and heir of John de Hothum late bishop of Ely, to Thomas de Ferrariis, knight, and Anne le Despenser late wife of Edward le Despenser, for their lives, remainder to Hugh le Despenser son of the said Ed- ward, and to Alice, John de Hothum's daughter, whom the said Hugh was to marry, and the heirs of their bodies. 68 This James III, earl of Ormond, was made lord justice of Ire- land on July 25, 1392, 16 R. II, and soon after routed the Mac- moynes, who had with a great force entered the county of Kilkenny. He continued in that dignity till the king, on Oct. 2, 1394, landed at Waterford with a mighty army, which procured him a ready submission from all the Irish princes and chieftains. Four of their great lords, called in their style kings, being pre- pared and instructed by the earl of Ormond, performed their vigils in Christ Church, were the next day, March 25, 1395, knighted in the same church by the king, and in robes agreeable to their state sat with him that day at his table. Upon the king's departure, the Byrnes rising in arms, the earl of Ormond (with Roger earl of March the lord lieutenant) wasted their lands in Wicklow, and took O'Byrne's castle. On Jan. 20, in 2 H. IV, Geoffrey O'Brenan, the head of his nation or sept, (as
THE INTRODUCTION. kxiii
I see by his instrument under seal,) " became the faithful man of the said earl and his heirs for ever, paying yearly to them six marks at or before the feast of All Saints as a token of his homage ; and in case any of his people commit traspass on the earl's people and tenants, or those of the county of Kilkenny, then the said Geoffrey and his heirs to pay to the said earl and his heirs double the said trespass, which in Irish is called Keyn and Ardkeyn, &c." This earl was made constable of Ireland in the 3d of Henry IV, according to the patent rolls of that year ; and in the next he appointed a deputy in that office. He was again made lord justice of the kingdom on Oct. 26, 1404, and in the April following held a parliament at Dublin, where the statutes of Dublin and Kilkenny and the charter of Ireland were con- firmed. He had good success, as well in repressing the depre-xxxvii dations of the Scots and Welsh upon the coasts, as in returning their outrages by making descents in their countries. He died possessed of this office of lord justice at Gowran on Sept. 7, 1405, 6 Henry IV.
69 This earl married Anne, daughter of John lord Welles, and by her had issue two sons, James IV earl of Ormond, and sir Richard le Botiller, to whom king Richard II was godfather, and whose descendants were afterwards earls of Ormond. He had likewise two illegitimate children ; viz. Thomas le Botiller, alias Baccagh, prior of Kilmainharn, a martial man, and lord justice of Ireland in 1408-9 and 1410, from whom come several good families of gentlemen in the counties of Kilkenny and Tip- perary ; and James le Botiller, alias Galdie, from whom the lords of Cahir (created barons in 1542) and divers other principal gentlemen in the counties of Tipperary and Waterford are de- scended. Mr. Butler, the clergyman, assigns him another le- gitimate son, named Edmund, from whom he pretends the Butlers of Sleewarden and Paulstown descend ; the former by his eldest, and the latter by a younger son, to whom he gives the name of Walter ; but this I am persuaded is a mistake, not only because no pedigree mentions this Edmund, but because Thomas, called Duffe earl of Ormond, when he entailed his estate upon the several branches of his family in the order of their descent from Edmund earl of Carrick, takes no notice of such a person or his descendant. This earl, James III, (as sir R. Rothe says,) built the castle of Dunfert, in the county of Kil- kenny; and in 1386 founded an house of friars minors at
Ixxiv THE INTRODUCTION.
Aylesbury, in Buckinghamshire, as Mr. Eoberts says upon the credit of a record in the office of arms in Ireland.
70 James IV earl of Ormond was not of full age when his father died, as (sir R. Rothe says) appeareth from a patent (7 Hen. IV) he had seen among the evidences of Thomas earl of Ormond, granting the wardship of the body and lands of the said earl to Thomas of Lancaster, (duke of Clarence,) second son to Henry IV, on the feast of exaltation of the cross, A. D. 1407. But soon after, the custody of the lands was put into other hands, as I see by a patent, under seal among the writings at Kilkenny, marked N°. 175, and dated at Dublin, Jan. 10, 8 H. IV, " wherein the king, with the consent of Stephen le Scrope, knight, deputy to his son Thomas of Lancastre, steward of Eng- land and lieutenant of Ireland, and of his council there, at the request of James le Botiller earl of Ermon, and to his use and profit, grants to Robert Habrich and Nicholas Stokes the custo- dium of all the castles and manors of Nenagh, Roscre, Thurles, Ardmaile, Milton, Cathyrdunesse, Inchecoyne, Balybothy, Car- rick-magriffin, Grenagh, Melonresyland, Dremdewny, Knoctofre, Kilkenny, Balygauran, Tallagh de Offelme, Ardelo, Bree, Rok- kelescourt, Cloncurry, and Blackcastel, with all other the lands, «fec., of James late earl of Ermon, father of the now said earl, whose heir he is, and who held of us in capite, which being the inheritance of the said heir, are by reason of his minority in our hands by the death of the late earl, to hold to the said Robert and Nicholas till the full age of the said heir, without paying any thing thereout to us, for the better government and susten- tation thereof," &c.
71 This earl's father had taken great care in his education; so that he was not only a man of good parts, but (which was very rare in noblemen at that time) master of a great deal of learn- ing. It was the general want of this in the laity of those ages, rather than any ambition of the clergy, (as some in their igno- rance of antiquity are apt to surmise,) which threw most of the great employments in the kingdom into the hands of the latter. It was then, and it ever will be, necessary to employ persons that can write and read ; but scarce any of the laity, even of the best families, were thus qualified ; and there is too much truth
in the complaint which abbe Vertot so often makes in his history xxxviii of the order of Malta, that for some hundreds of years there was scarce a knight of that order, though all of noble families,
THE INTRODUCTION. Ixxv
that could so much as write his name, so that the vice-chan- cellor, who committed all the acts of their chapters to writing, was always a clergyman. And whenever a set of proud fellows, that will suffer nobody to know more or think otherwise than themselves, or of young and vain ones, that fancy themselves to be finely accomplished, because they have learned to chatter a foreign language, and have seen some fine buildings abroad in countries, with regard to the commerce, laws, police, and consti- tution whereof they perhaps never asked a question nor made an observation, shall so far prevail as to put an university educa- tion out of countenance, and cause it to be generally disused, their lay posterity will probably owe it to them that they are necessitated to be as illiterate, and withal full as insignificant, as any of their ancestors. The great advantage of learning in those days we see remarkably in the case of this earl of Ormond of whom I am speaking. It did not render him less martial than any of his predecessors ; for before he was of age, he accom- panied sir Stephen Scrope, the lord deputy, into the field, when he invaded the territory of Mac Morrogh, routed the Irish of that sept, took O'Nolan and his son prisoner, and, marching from thence to Kalian in the county of Kilkenny with great ex- pedition, surprised the rebels, defeating their whole force and leaving O'Carol with eight hundred of his men dead upon the field of battle. But it was even thought to qualify him for the highest trusts and employments before the law deemed him fit to enjoy his estate ; for in this same year, 1407, Stephen Scrope going over into England, this earl of Ormond, not yet of age, was left lord deputy in his stead to govern the kingdom. His commission for that office bears date 18 Dec. 9 H. IV, and constitutes u James earl of Ormond lord deputy of Ireland dur- ing the absence of Stephen Scrope kt. deputy to the said Thomas of Lancaster, taking notice of the said earl's being then the king's ward, and his wardship being granted to the said duke, as hath been said before." This young governor held a parliament in the spring following at Dublin, in which the sta- tutes of Kilkenny and Dublin were confirmed, and the charter against purveyors enacted.
72 Thomas of Lancaster, the lord lieutenant, came over soon after ; with whom the earl of Ormond contracted such a friend- ship, that when he went, in 1412, over into France, the earl ac- companied him in his travels. In 1420, having attended king
Ixxvi THE INTRODUCTION.
Henry V in his wars in Normandy, he was sent over lord lieu- tenant into Ireland, and on April 4 landed at Waterford ; and presently after a combat was fought before him between two of his cousins, one of which died in the field, and the other was carried off sore wounded to Kilkenny. On St. George's day he held a council and summoned a parliament to meet at Dublin ; and in the meantime he made an expedition into Ulster, and overran the country of O'Rely, Mac Mahon, and Macgwire. In 1422, O'More having on May 7 attacked and killed some of his servants, and besieged two hundred more, that fled for refuge to the abbey of Leix, the earl of Ormond immediately invaded his country, and with a small party defeated his terrible army in the red bog of Athy, relieved his own men, spoiled and burnt the rebels' lands for four days together, till they sued for peace and made their submission. Mac Mahon was at this time destroying all before him in Urgal, but the earl, returning from his expe- dition against O'More, soon forced him to submit. Many other noble exploits were done by him in the course of his government, which continued till some time after the death of Henry V, when Edmund Mortimer, earl of March and Ulster, was sent over lord lieutenant.
73 In 1426, James earl of Ormond was again made chief go-xxxix vernor, by the style of lord lieutenant for two years, but on Aug. i in the year following surrendered the sword to sir John de Grey. In 1440 he was appointed lord lieutenant, and had the temporalities of the see of Cashel granted to him for ten years after the death of Richard O'Hedian. He continued in his post till William Welles came over, in 1442, as deputy to his brother Lion lord Welles ; but in the year following, the earl of Ormond was again made lord lieutenant ; and in 23 H. VI ob- tained a license to be absent for several years, without incurring the penalty of the statute of 3 R. II touching absentees. He continued in the government till John Talbot earl of Shrews- bury came over, at the latter end of 1446, as lord lieutenant. There had been for many years a violent feud between the two families, and Talbot, returning the next year to England, ac- cused the earl of Ormond of treason, but the king quashed the accusation. Richard Talbot, archbishop of Dublin, whom the earl of Shrewsbury had left deputy, did what he could to revive it, though other bishops, and the lords Barry, Roche, and other temporal peers, gave a full testimonial to the earl of Ormond's
THE INTRODUCTION. Ixxvii
great services. Thomas Fitz Gerot, prior of Kilmainham, one of the archbishop's partisans, was sent over to London to renew the accusation ; and, by sentence of the constable and earl mar- shal, the combat was appointed between them in Smithfield, but the king interposed in the matter, and would not suffer it to proceed. His majesty thought fit, on this occasion, " to examine into the cause, manner, and circumstances of the accusation; and by the clear testimony of several of the nobility and other persons of credit, as well as by undoubted evidence in writing, was fully convinced that it arose purely from pique and malice, and therefore ordered all the proceedings to be cancelled ; de- clared by letters patents of 20 Sept. 27 H. VI, enrolled in the chancery of Ireland, that the earl of Ormond was faithful in his allegiance, meritorious in his services, and whole and untainted in his fame ; that nobody should dare, on pain of his indigna- tion, to revive the accusation, reproach his conduct, or throw a blot on his character ; and that his accusers were men of no credit, nor should their testimony be admitted in any case." And a writ reciting all this, dated the 2ist of Nov. following, and attested by the earl's mortal enemy, Richard archbishop of Dublin, then lord deputy, was sent to the magistrates of Lime- rick and other cities, to cause proclamation to be made thereof all over the kingdom.
74 James IV earl of Ormond was at this time about sixty years of age : he lived to see the good government of Richard duke of York in Ireland; who coming over thither in 1449, had a son born at Dublin the year following, known afterwards by the name of George duke of Clarence, to whom the earls of Ormond and Desmond were godfathers. This earl, commonly called the White earl of Ormond, died at Atherdee, in the county of Louth, on St. Bartholomew's eve, Aug. 23, 1452, and was buried in the church of the abbey of St. Mary in Dublin. He married for his first wife Joane daughter and heir-general to Gerald Fitz- Gerald earl of Kildare, who died at London, without issue, on Aug. 3, 1430, and was buried in the church of the hospital of S. Thomas de Acres ; the earl her husband being at that time abroad with the king in France. He married, soon after, Elizabeth widow of John lord Grey, and daughter to William Beauchamp lord Bergaveny, as appears by a pardon under the great seal, in the 10 H. VI, to that lady for this marriage, which is preserved among the evidences of the Ormond family. By this second bed
kxviii THE INTRODUCTION.
he had three sons, James, John, and Thomas, who one after another succeeded to his honours ; and one daughter, named Elizabeth, who was married to John Talbot, the second earl of xl Shrewsbury. This second wife seems to have died as soon as she had been the mother of these children, for she is not men- tioned in her mother Joane lady Bergaveny's will, dated Jan. 10, 1434, who yet left legacies to all her children, and more be- quests to her relations and servants than are usual. The will is printed in sir W. Dugdale's Baronage, vol. i. p. 240.
75 This earl of Ormond was a great student and lover of history and antiquity. He was a great proficient in the laws of arms and matters of honour, and well versed in everything that apper- tained to the nobility. He gave for ever to the College of Heralds in England lands of his ancient inheritance, which in queen Elizabeth's time yielded the rent of i ool. a year ; and until the reformation of religion in that kingdom he was always prayed for in all their public meetings for cases of honour, and was afterwards, till the rebellion of 1641, remembered in all those meetings as one of their public and special benefactors. It was at his request, and in the time of his government of Ireland, that king Henry V created John Kitely, one of the college of heralds in England, king of arms of all Ireland, by the name and title of Ireland; which title his successors continued as long as the kings of England styled themselves lords of Ireland. But after Henry VIII took upon him the style of king of that realm, it was thought fit that the king of arms next created should quit that title, and assume the name of Ulster king of arms of all Ireland, the earldom of Ulster being the chief royal appenage devolved to the crown. The first that bore the title of Ulster was Narbon, who in the time of Henry VIII was Richmond he- rald in England. It was this earl that granted the manor and advowson of Huckcote, in the county of Bucks, to the hospital of St. Thomas de Acres in London, though it was his son who, in the year after his death, obtained (as hath been said) a con- firmation of that grant in parliament.
76 James V earl of Ormond succeeded his father, and was the first of his family after their settlement in Ireland that was not left a minor, but came immediately into the possession of his fa- ther's estate. He derived also a very considerable one from his grandmother Joane, widow of William Beauchamp lord Berga- veny, which after her death was conveyed to him by her feoffees.
THE INTRODUCTION. kxix
The deed bears date on Saturday next before the feast of St. Martin the Bishop, 15 H. VI, A.D. 1436; and thereby John Bathe, clerk, Robert Darcy, Bartholomew Brokesby, Henry Fylongley, Water Kebbyl, Henry Brokesby, esquires, William Newport, clerk, and John Bultus, convey to Thomas Burton and John Daundsey junior the manors of Gannow Clent, Haggeley, Wolverley, Snodesbury, and the provostship of Snodesbury, the manor of Old Swynford and Oydal de Old Swynford, in the county of Worcester; the manors of Dudston, Cordesley in Aston, and Heybarnes, with their appurtenances, in Warwick- shire; the manor of Pycheford, in Shropshire; the manors of Russel Nath, Hannesworth, and .... in Staffordshire ; the manors of Newport-Paynel and Lynford Poor, in the county of Bucks ; the manors of Rochford, Pakelsham, Foulnesse, Lyghe, and Doggetley, in Essex, &c. ; to hold and enjoy for four years, and afterwards to enure to James son and heir to James earl of Ormond, and the heirs male of his body lawfully begotten ; and failing such issue, then to John Botiller, second son to the said earl, and the heirs male of his body ; and failing his issue, then to Thomas Botiller, third son to the said earl, and the heirs male of his body ; and failing such issue, to the right heirs of James earl of Ormond aforesaid.
77 James V earl of Ormond was very young when he was knighted by king Henry VI, and attended Richard duke of York in his expedition into France, whereof that duke was made regent. In 1449 he was created earl of Wiltshire by a patent bearing xli date at Winton, July 8, 27 H. VI, and in the year following he was constituted one of the commissioners, to whom the custody of the town and castle of Calais, with the tower of Rysbank and the marshes of Picardie was committed for five years. In 1451 he was lord deputy of Ireland in the absence of the duke of York ; and in the next year, upon his father's death, was made lord lieutenant of that kingdom, by a commission granting him that dignity for ten years. In 32 H. VI, with the earls of Salisbury and other great lords, he undertook the guarding of the seas for three years, receiving the tonnage and poundage to support the charge thereof; and in the 33d of that king was made lord treasurer of England, but held that post no longer than the May following, when the battle of St. Alban's being fought, and Henry VI, on whose side he fought, being taken prisoner, the duke of York was declared protector of the
Ixxx THE INTRODUCTION.
kingdom. This eaiTs commission for the government of Ireland was then superseded, and the duke of York declared lord lieutenant. In 37 H. VI, that duke being discharged of his protectorship, the earl of Wiltshire and Ormond was restored to the post of lord treasurer, and the next year made knight of the garter. He obtained also at the same time a grant of the keepership of the forest or park of Pederton in com. Somerset1, then in the crown by the forfeiture of Richard duke of York, and of Cranburne chase in the counties of Wilts and Dorset. He soon after fitted out five great ships of Genoa to fight the earl of Warwick's fleet at sea, and sailed with them to the Netherlands ; but returned before the battle of Wakefield, on Dec. 31, 1460, in which he commanded one wing of the army, which enclosed the duke of York, who was there slain, oppressed with numbers. On the 2d of February following, leading with Jasper earl of Pembroke a body of Welsh and Irish against Edward earl of March, he was defeated with the loss of 3800 men at Mortimer's Cross near Ludlow. On March 29, 1461, he was at the bloody battle of Towton in Yorkshire, and was taken prisoner after the defeat by Richard Salkeld esquire, and was beheaded on the first of May at Newcastle.
78 This earl married to his first wife Avicia daughter to John Fitz-Alan earl of Arundel, sister and heir to Humphrey her brother. His second wife was Avicia daughter of sir Richard Stafford, a great heiress. His third was Eleanor, sister and one of the coheirs of Edmund Beaufort duke of Somerset. It was this last match which engaged him in the Lancastrian cause. He left no issue by any of his wives, but had a natural son, sir James Ormond, commonly called Black James, who proved a valiant but quarrelsome man, and did good service against the Geral- dines, when Lambert Simnel was cried up amongst the Irish ; for which he was knighted by Henry VII. In 1492, he was made lord treasurer of Ireland in the room of the lord Portlester ; and going over thither in June with a small band of soldiers, a quarrel happened between him and the earl of Kildare, a skirmish ensued, which was the beginning of the feud between the Butlers and the Geraldines, which lasted so long, to the infinite prejudice of both families. He not only ravaged the earl of Kildare's lands, but quarrelling with sir Piers Butler, and keeping him out of his estate by force, was pierced through with his dart between Dunmore and Kilkenny, on March 1 7, 151 8. The earl of Wiltshire
THE INTRODUCTION. Ixxxi
and Ormond was at his death seized of the following lands in England ; — the manor of Torre-Brian in Devonshire, the manors of Mere, Hondesworth,